Menear Matthew, Gilbert Michel, Fleury Marie-Josée
Département de médecine familiale et médecine d'urgence, Université Laval - Centre de recherche du CHU de Québec - Université Laval.
Centre national d'excellence en santé mentale, Direction de la santé mentale, Ministère de la Santé et des Services sociaux.
Sante Ment Que. 2017 Spring;42(1):243-271.
Objective The objectives of this review were to identify and compare major international initiatives aiming to integrate mental health services in primary care and to summarize the lessons learned for similar integration efforts in the province of Quebec, Canada.Methods We conducted a narrative review of the literature guided by a conceptual framework drawn from the literature on integrated care. We identified relevant initiatives to support primary mental health care integration through Pubmed searches and through previous systematic reviews on this topic. We then selected those initiatives that provided sufficient details on their key characteristics, outcomes, and implementation issues (e.g. barriers, facilitators). We focused our analysis on large-scale initiatives as these offered the most potential for impacts on population mental health. This process resulted in the selection of 20 initiatives that were described in 153 articles and reports. Our synthesis was guided by our conceptual framework, which distinguishes between five types of integration, namely clinical, professional, organizational, systemic and functional integration.Results Of the 20 primary mental health care integration initiatives, 3 targeted youth, 14 targeted adults or multiple age groups, and 3 were targeted towards seniors. Most initiatives aimed to implement collaborative care models for common mental disorders in primary care. Other initiatives focused on co-locating mental health professionals in primary care, supporting the emergence of a diversity of integration projects led by community-based primary care practices, or the merger of primary care and mental health organizations. Most initiatives were based on clinical, professional and functional integration strategies. Across initiatives, a range of positive outcomes were reported, notably to the accessibility and quality of services, the satisfaction of patients and providers, the costs of services, and impacts on patients' health and quality of life. Integration initiatives encountered many common barriers to implementation. However, steps taken to properly prepare and execute the implementation process, as well as ensure the sustainability of initiatives, helped initiative leaders to overcome certain barriers. The lessons for Quebec include the need to continue to reinforce evidence-based models of collaborative mental health care in primary care and promote a culture of continuous quality improvement and a more widespread use of information technologies that can support integrated care.Conclusion This review shows that integrating mental health services into primary care is a complex process that depends on a variety of strategies occurring at multiple levels of the healthcare system. However, it is also a unifying process that holds much potential to significantly impact the mental health and well-being of populations.
目的 本综述的目的是识别和比较旨在将精神卫生服务纳入初级保健的主要国际举措,并总结加拿大魁北克省在类似整合工作中吸取的经验教训。方法 我们以综合护理文献中的概念框架为指导,对文献进行了叙述性综述。我们通过PubMed搜索以及此前关于该主题的系统综述,识别出支持初级精神卫生保健整合的相关举措。然后,我们选择了那些在关键特征、结果和实施问题(如障碍、促进因素)方面提供了足够详细信息的举措。我们将分析重点放在大规模举措上,因为这些举措对人群精神卫生的影响潜力最大。这一过程最终选定了20项举措,它们在153篇文章和报告中有所描述。我们的综合分析以我们的概念框架为指导,该框架区分了五种整合类型,即临床整合、专业整合、组织整合、系统整合和功能整合。结果 在20项初级精神卫生保健整合举措中,3项针对青少年,14项针对成年人或多个年龄组,3项针对老年人。大多数举措旨在为初级保健中的常见精神障碍实施协作护理模式。其他举措则侧重于在初级保健中安排精神卫生专业人员,支持由社区初级保健机构主导的各种整合项目的出现,或初级保健与精神卫生组织的合并。大多数举措基于临床、专业和功能整合策略。在各项举措中,报告了一系列积极成果,特别是在服务的可及性和质量、患者及提供者的满意度、服务成本以及对患者健康和生活质量的影响方面。整合举措在实施过程中遇到了许多常见障碍。然而,为妥善准备和执行实施过程以及确保举措的可持续性而采取的措施,帮助举措负责人克服了某些障碍。对魁北克省的经验教训包括需要继续加强初级保健中基于证据的协作精神卫生护理模式,促进持续质量改进的文化,并更广泛地使用能够支持综合护理的信息技术。结论 本综述表明,将精神卫生服务纳入初级保健是一个复杂的过程,取决于医疗保健系统多个层面上发生的各种策略。然而,这也是一个具有很大潜力对人群的精神卫生和福祉产生重大影响的统一过程。