DREPAGREFFE试验设计:一项前瞻性对照多中心研究,评估基因相同的造血干细胞移植相对于慢性输血对经颅多普勒检测有中风风险的镰状细胞贫血儿童的益处(NCT 01340404)。
Design of the DREPAGREFFE trial: A prospective controlled multicenter study evaluating the benefit of genoidentical hematopoietic stem cell transplantation over chronic transfusion in sickle cell anemia children detected to be at risk of stroke by transcranial Doppler (NCT 01340404).
作者信息
Chevret Sylvie, Verlhac Suzanne, Ducros-Miralles Elisabeth, Dalle Jean-Hugues, de Latour Regis Peffault, de Montalembert Mariane, Benkerrou Malika, Pondarré Corinne, Thuret Isabelle, Guitton Corinne, Lesprit Emmanuelle, Etienne-Julan Maryse, Elana Gisèle, Vannier Jean-Pierre, Lutz Patrick, Neven Bénédicte, Galambrun Claire, Paillard Catherine, Runel Camille, Jubert Charlotte, Arnaud Cécile, Kamdem Annie, Brousse Valentine, Missud Florence, Petras Marie, Doumdo-Divialle Lydia, Berger Claire, Fréard Françoise, Taieb Olivier, Drain Elise, Elmaleh Monique, Vasile Manuela, Khelif Yacine, Bernaudin Myriam, Chadebech Philippe, Pirenne France, Socié Gérard, Bernaudin Françoise
机构信息
Statistical, Methodology Department, Paris-St-Louis Hospital, Paris-Diderot University, France.
Medical Imaging Department, Referral Center for Sickle Cell Disease, Créteil-CHIC Hospital, Créteil, France; Pediatric Imaging Department, Robert-Debré Hospital, Paris-Diderot University, France.
出版信息
Contemp Clin Trials. 2017 Nov;62:91-104. doi: 10.1016/j.cct.2017.08.008. Epub 2017 Aug 15.
BACKGROUND
Children with sickle cell anemia (SCA) have an 11% risk of stroke by the age of 18. Chronic transfusion applied in patients detected to be at risk by transcranial Doppler allows a significant reduction of stroke risk. However, chronic transfusion exposes to several adverse events, including alloimmunization and iron overload, and is not curative. Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation allows termination of the transfusion program, but its benefit has not been demonstrated.
DESIGN
DREPAGREFFE (NCT01340404) is a multicenter, prospective trial enrolling SCA children younger than 15years receiving chronic transfusion due to a history of abnormal transcranial Doppler (velocities ≥200cm/s). Only those with at least one non-SCA sibling and parents accepting HLA-typing and transplantation with a genoidentical donor were eligible. Chronic transfusion was pursued in patients with no available donor, whereas others were transplanted. Comparison between the 2 arms (transfusion vs transplantation) was analyzed using both genetic randomization and propensity-score matching as a sensitivity analysis. The primary end-point was the velocity measure at 1year. Secondary endpoints were the incidence of stroke, silent cerebral infarcts and stenoses, cognitive performance in comparison with siblings, allo-immunization, iron-overload, phosphatidyl-serine, angiogenesis/hypoxia, brain injury-related factor expression, quality of life and cost.
OBJECTIVES
To show that genoidentical transplantation decreases velocities significantly more than chronic transfusion in SCA children at risk of stroke.
DISCUSSION
DREPAGREFFE is the first prospective study to evaluate transplantation in SCA children. It compares the outcome of cerebral vasculopathy following genoidentical transplantation versus chronic transfusion using genetic randomization and causal inference methods.
背景
镰状细胞贫血(SCA)患儿在18岁时发生中风的风险为11%。对经颅多普勒检测有中风风险的患者进行长期输血可显著降低中风风险。然而,长期输血会引发多种不良事件,包括同种免疫和铁过载,且无法治愈疾病。造血干细胞移植可终止输血方案,但其益处尚未得到证实。
设计
DREPAGREFFE(NCT01340404)是一项多中心前瞻性试验,纳入15岁以下因经颅多普勒异常(速度≥200cm/s)而接受长期输血的SCA患儿。只有那些至少有一个非SCA同胞且父母接受HLA分型并愿意接受与基因相同供体进行移植的患儿才有资格参加。没有合适供体的患者继续接受长期输血,其他患者则接受移植。使用基因随机化和倾向评分匹配作为敏感性分析,对两组(输血组与移植组)进行比较分析。主要终点是1年时的速度测量值。次要终点包括中风、无症状脑梗死和狭窄的发生率、与同胞相比的认知表现、同种免疫、铁过载、磷脂酰丝氨酸、血管生成/缺氧、脑损伤相关因子表达、生活质量和成本。
目的
证明在有中风风险的SCA患儿中,与长期输血相比,基因相同的移植能更显著地降低血流速度。
讨论
DREPAGREFFE是第一项评估SCA患儿移植情况的前瞻性研究。它使用基因随机化和因果推断方法,比较了基因相同的移植与长期输血后脑血管病变的结果。