Novel Transfer of Care Sign-out Assessment Tool in a Pediatric Emergency Department.

OBJECTIVE

Transfer of care sign-outs (TOCS) for admissions from a pediatric emergency department have unique challenges. Standardized and reliable assessment tools for TOCS remain elusive. We describe the development, reliability, and validity of a TOCS assessment tool.

METHODS

Video recordings of resident TOCS were assessed to capture 4 domains: completeness, synopsis, foresight, and professionalism. In phase 1, 56 TOCS were used to modify the tool and improve reliability. In phase 2, 91 TOCS were used to examine validity. Analyses included Cronbach's alpha for internal structure, intraclass correlation and Cohen's kappa for interrater reliability, Pearson's correlation for relationships between variables, and 95% confidence interval of the mean for resident group comparisons.

RESULTS

Cronbach's alpha was 0.52 for internal structure of the tool's subjective rating scale. Intraclass correlation for the subjective rating scale items ranged from 0.70 to 0.80. Cohen's kappa for most objective checklist items ranged from 0.43 to 1. Content completeness was significantly correlated with synopsis, foresight, and professionalism (Pearson's r ranged from 0.36 to 0.62, P values were <0.001). House staff senior residents scored higher (on average) than interns and rotating senior residents in synopsis and foresight. Also, house staff interns scored higher (on average) than rotating senior residents in professionalism. House staff senior residents scored higher (on average) than rotating senior residents in content completeness.

CONCLUSIONS

We provide validity evidence to support using scores from the TOCS tool to assess higher-level transfer of care comprehension and communication by pediatric emergency department residents and to test interventions to improve TOCS.