Lawlor Jennifer A, McGirr Sara
Michigan State University, 316 Physics Rd., Rm 262, East Lansing, MI 48824, United States.
Eval Program Plann. 2017 Dec;65:131-138. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2017.08.015. Epub 2017 Aug 30.
Recently, systems thinking and systems science approaches have gained popularity in the field of evaluation; however, there has been relatively little exploration of how evaluators could use quantitative tools to assist in the implementation of systems approaches therein. The purpose of this paper is to explore potential uses of one such quantitative tool, agent-based modeling, in evaluation practice. To this end, we define agent-based modeling and offer potential uses for it in typical evaluation activities, including: engaging stakeholders, selecting an intervention, modeling program theory, setting performance targets, and interpreting evaluation results. We provide demonstrative examples from published agent-based modeling efforts both inside and outside the field of evaluation for each of the evaluative activities discussed. We further describe potential pitfalls of this tool and offer cautions for evaluators who may chose to implement it in their practice. Finally, the article concludes with a discussion of the future of agent-based modeling in evaluation practice and a call for more formal exploration of this tool as well as other approaches to simulation modeling in the field.
最近,系统思维和系统科学方法在评估领域颇受青睐;然而,对于评估人员如何运用定量工具来协助在该领域实施系统方法,相关探索相对较少。本文旨在探讨一种此类定量工具——基于主体的建模在评估实践中的潜在用途。为此,我们对基于主体的建模进行了定义,并阐述了其在典型评估活动中的潜在用途,包括:让利益相关者参与、选择干预措施、构建项目理论模型、设定绩效目标以及解读评估结果。对于所讨论的各项评估活动,我们提供了评估领域内外已发表的基于主体建模成果的示范示例。我们进一步描述了该工具的潜在陷阱,并为可能选择在实践中应用它的评估人员提供了注意事项。最后,本文以对基于主体建模在评估实践中的未来的讨论作为结尾,并呼吁对该工具以及该领域中其他模拟建模方法进行更正式的探索。