Supination Contractures in Brachial Plexus Birth Palsy: Long-Term Upper Limb Function and Recurrence After Forearm Osteotomy or Nonsurgical Treatment.

PURPOSE

Forearm osteotomy for supination deformity in brachial plexus birth palsy (BPBP) may lead to improved function of the upper limb. However, recurrence rates are high and limit satisfactory results.

METHODS

We reviewed the long-term outcome of the entire upper limb of 22 BPBP patients with a supination contracture who were treated by forearm osteotomy and compared them with an age-matched group that was treated nonsurgically (n = 28). Recurrence was defined as a passive pronation below 30°.

RESULTS

The median follow-up was 5.0 years (range, 1.5-14 years). The mean passive pronation after forearm osteotomy, including patients with recurrence at follow-up, improved from -1° (SD, 9°) to 33° (SD, 48°) at final follow-up, mean active wrist extension improved from 23° (SD, 40°) to 41° (SD, 38°). An overall improvement of wrist and hand strength was present. In patients without recurrence, pronation improved to a mean of 66° (SD, 23°) at final follow-up. Recurrence of the supination contracture was present in 9 cases (41%) and was only present in patients with a single bone osteotomy. Recurrence was associated with lower age at surgery (recurrence mean, 4 [SD, 1.2] and no recurrence 8 [SD 4.5]), lower shoulder external rotation (recurrence mean, 28 [SD, 17] and no recurrence 49 [SD, 23]), and overall lower hand function at baseline.

CONCLUSIONS

Forearm osteotomy improves forearm pronation and hand function. Recurrence should be considered as a potential complication after forearm osteotomy and is associated with young age and lower function of shoulder and hand. Single-bone osteotomy might also be a risk factor for recurrence.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic IV.