Parekh Manoj, Ramaiah Girisha, Pashilkar Prachi, Ramanujam Ranjani, Johnston Peter, Ilag Leodevico L
The Apollo Clinic, Frazer Town, Bangalore, India.
Mahaveer Jain Hospital, Bangalore, India.
BMC Complement Altern Med. 2017 Sep 18;17(1):464. doi: 10.1186/s12906-017-1970-2.
Most of the current anti-fungal treatments are chemical-based, fungistatic, have low efficacy in the treatment of tinea and toxicity concerns, while onychomycosis remains recalcitrant to most antifungal therapies. The study aimed to establish the fungicidal, efficacy and safety profile of Calmagen® dermaceutical cream and lotion containing AMYCOT® as a topical treatment in patients with severe to very severe presentations of fungal skin (tinea) and nail infections (onychomycosis).
A randomized, placebo-controlled, double blind, parallel, single centre study was conducted on 28 subjects with severe to very severe tinea or onychomycosis. All patients were randomized in a ratio of 1:1 for treatment or placebo group. Subjects in the treatment arm received Calmagen® cream or lotion, while subjects in the placebo arm received a similar inert topical preparation. Tinea subjects were treated with cream for four weeks, while onychomycosis subjects were treated with lotion for 12 weeks. Mycological cure, the primary endpoint, was assessed by three parameters: KOH (potassium hydroxide) smear, fungal culture and live spore count. Clinical cure was defined as Investigator Global Assessment (IGA) response of 'cleared' or 'excellent'.
All three parameters constituting mycological cure were confirmed in 92.8% (13/14) of subjects in the treatment arm, while all 14 subjects in the placebo arm remained positive for KOH smear. Calmagen® cream and lotion treatment showed a significant improvement in all three parameters: KOH smear, (95% CI (Calmagen): 79.4, 100.0; 95% CI (placebo): 0.0, 0.0; p < 0.0001); fungal culture (95% CI (Calmagen); 100.0, 100.0; 95% CI (Placebo): 17.0, 100.0; p < 0.0019); and live spore count (95% CI (Calmagen): 100.0, 100.0; 95% CI (Placebo): 17.0, 100.0; p < 0.0019). Clinical cure was achieved in all subjects in the treatment arm while none in the placebo arm were clinically cured. No treatment-related adverse effects were observed in either group.
The Calmagen® cream and lotion containing AMYCOT® represent a potentially safe and efficacious natural alternative in the treatment of Tinea and onychomycosis.
This trial has been registered with the clinical trial registry-India (CTRI; registration number: CTRI/2012/03/002522 ).
目前大多数抗真菌治疗都是基于化学药物,具有抑菌作用,治疗癣病时疗效较低且存在毒性问题,而甲癣对大多数抗真菌疗法仍具有顽固性。本研究旨在确定含有AMYCOT®的Calmagen®皮肤乳膏和洗剂作为局部治疗对患有重度至极重度真菌性皮肤(癣)和指甲感染(甲癣)患者的杀菌效果、疗效和安全性。
对28例患有重度至极重度癣或甲癣的受试者进行了一项随机、安慰剂对照、双盲、平行、单中心研究。所有患者按1:1的比例随机分为治疗组或安慰剂组。治疗组的受试者接受Calmagen®乳膏或洗剂,而安慰剂组的受试者接受类似的惰性局部制剂。癣病受试者用乳膏治疗四周,而甲癣受试者用洗剂治疗12周。主要终点真菌学治愈通过三个参数进行评估:氢氧化钾(KOH)涂片、真菌培养和活孢子计数。临床治愈定义为研究者整体评估(IGA)为“清除”或“极佳”的反应。
治疗组92.8%(13/14)的受试者的构成真菌学治愈的所有三个参数均得到确认,而安慰剂组的所有14名受试者的KOH涂片均为阳性。Calmagen®乳膏和洗剂治疗在所有三个参数上均显示出显著改善:KOH涂片(95%置信区间(Calmagen):79.4,100.0;95%置信区间(安慰剂):0.0,0.0;p<0.0001);真菌培养(95%置信区间(Calmagen):100.0,100.0;95%置信区间(安慰剂):17.0,100.0;p<0.0019);以及活孢子计数(95%置信区间(Calmagen):100.0,100.0;95%置信区间(安慰剂):17.0,100.0;p<0.0019)。治疗组的所有受试者均实现了临床治愈,而安慰剂组无一例实现临床治愈。两组均未观察到与治疗相关的不良反应。
含有AMYCOT®的Calmagen®乳膏和洗剂是治疗癣和甲癣的一种潜在安全有效的天然替代药物。
本试验已在印度临床试验注册中心(CTRI)注册(注册号:CTRI/2012/03/002522)。