Shu Guocheng, Gong Yuzhou, Xie Feng, Wu Nicholas C, Li Cheng
Chengdu Institute of Biology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Chengdu, Sichuan, China.
University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China.
PeerJ. 2017 Sep 15;5:e3805. doi: 10.7717/peerj.3805. eCollection 2017.
Measurements of historical specimens are widely applied in studies of taxonomy, systematics, and ecology, but biologists often assume that the effects of preservative chemicals on the morphology of amphibian specimens are minimal in their analyses. We compared the body length and body mass of 182 samples of 13 live and preserved (up to 10 years) anuran species and found that the body length and body mass of preserved specimens significantly decreased by 6.1% and 24.8%, respectively, compared to those measurements of their live counterparts. The changes in body length and mass also exhibited highly significant variations between species. Similarly, there were significant differences in shrinkage of body length and body mass between sexes, where males showed greater shrinkage in body length and body mass compared to females. Preservation distorted the magnitude of the interspecific differences in body length observed in the fresh specimens. Overall, the reduction in body length or mass was greater in longer or heavier individuals. Due to the effects of preservation on amphibian morphology, we propose two parsimonious conversion equations to back-calculate the original body length and body mass of studied anurans for researchers working with historical data, since morphological data from preserved specimens may lead to incorrect biological interpretations when comparing to fresh specimens. Therefore, researchers should correct for errors due to preservation effects that may lead to the misinterpretation of results.
历史标本的测量在分类学、系统学和生态学研究中被广泛应用,但生物学家在分析时通常假定防腐化学物质对两栖动物标本形态的影响极小。我们比较了13种活体和保存(长达10年)无尾目物种的182个样本的体长和体重,发现与活体对应样本的测量值相比,保存标本的体长和体重分别显著下降了6.1%和24.8%。体长和体重的变化在不同物种间也表现出高度显著的差异。同样,两性在体长和体重收缩方面存在显著差异,雄性在体长和体重上的收缩比雌性更大。保存扭曲了新鲜标本中观察到的种间体长差异幅度。总体而言,个体越长或越重,其体长或体重的减少幅度越大。由于保存对两栖动物形态的影响,我们提出了两个简约的转换方程,供处理历史数据的研究人员反推所研究无尾目动物的原始体长和体重,因为与新鲜标本相比,保存标本的形态数据在比较时可能导致错误的生物学解释。因此,研究人员应校正可能导致结果误判的保存效应误差。