Faculty of Nutrition, Kagawa Nutrition University, 3-9-21 Chiyoda, Sakado, Saitama 350-0288, Japan.
Asken division, Green House Co., Ltd., 3-20-2 Nishishinjyuku, Shinjyuku-ku, Tokyo 163-1477, Japan.
Nutrients. 2017 Sep 24;9(10):1058. doi: 10.3390/nu9101058.
We compared the relative validity of nutrient intakes derived from Internet website dish-based dietary records (WDDRs) and weighed dietary records (DRs). The study participants were 218 registered users of a dietary management website. After excluding 55 participants, a total of 163 participants were included in the final analyses. The participants were Japanese women, and their mean age and mean body mass index (BMI) were 39.3 (±10.3) years and 22.3 (±3.7) years, respectively. We compared differences in the DR and WDDR with respect to intakes of energy and 13 nutrients. The median values for the intake of protein and seven nutrients showed no significant difference between the DR and WDDR, and the estimated values were generally similar. The interquartile range of nutrients with a significant difference did not show a large deviation, with the exception of vitamin A. Correlation coefficients showed a strong correlation of 0.7, with the exception of sodium and vitamin E. The kappa coefficients for energy and for some nutrients were good to fair. Using Bland-Altman plots, we found proportional errors in the intake values for vitamins and minerals. We could not confirm obvious systematic errors for energy, protein, fat, or carbohydrate intake. WDDR use is considered to be a valid method for estimating energy and nutrient intakes among Japanese women.
我们比较了来源于互联网网站膳食记录(WDDR)和称重膳食记录(DR)的营养素摄入量的相对有效性。研究参与者为饮食管理网站的 218 名注册用户。排除 55 名参与者后,共有 163 名参与者纳入最终分析。参与者为日本女性,平均年龄和平均体重指数(BMI)分别为 39.3(±10.3)岁和 22.3(±3.7)岁。我们比较了 DR 和 WDDR 对于能量和 13 种营养素摄入量的差异。DR 和 WDDR 之间的蛋白质和七种营养素的摄入量中位数没有显著差异,估计值通常相似。除维生素 A 外,具有显著差异的营养素的四分位间距没有大的偏差。相关系数显示除了钠和维生素 E 外,具有较强的相关性为 0.7。能量和某些营养素的kappa 系数为良好至一般。使用 Bland-Altman 图,我们发现维生素和矿物质摄入量的比例误差。我们不能确认能量、蛋白质、脂肪或碳水化合物摄入存在明显的系统误差。WDDR 的使用被认为是一种估计日本女性能量和营养素摄入量的有效方法。