Gorka Christine, Craig Jana M, Spielman Bethany J
a Clinical Ethics Center , Memorial Medical Center.
b Northern California (NCAL) Program in Clinical & Organizational Ethics, Kaiser Permanente.
AJOB Empir Bioeth. 2017 Apr-Jun;8(2):116-127. doi: 10.1080/23294515.2017.1292327. Epub 2017 Feb 7.
Little is known about what factors may contribute to the growth of a consultation service or how a practice may change or evolve across time.
This study examines data collected from a busy ethics consultation service over a period of more than two decades.
We report a number of longitudinal findings that represent significant growth in the volume of ethics consultation requests from 19 in 1990 to 551 in 2013, as well as important changes in the patient population for which ethics help is requested. The findings include (1) a steady growth in requests from primary care providers (e.g., physicians and nurses), as well as increases in ancillary services (e.g., social workers); (2) a decrease in length of stay (days) before ethics help is requested; (3) an increase in the reasons that individuals ask for help from ethics; (4) an upsurge in consults requests from areas outside the intensive care unit (ICU); (5) a decrease in patients that died during hospitalization (e.g., live discharges); and (6) growth in the numbers of patients lacking decision-making capacity.
We believe the increases in consult requests reflect appropriate and necessary growth because recent consultations have also been associated with consultations requiring (7) additional interventions and (8) reasonably high time intensity scores.
对于哪些因素可能促使会诊服务的增长,或者一种业务如何随时间变化或发展,人们了解甚少。
本研究考察了从一项繁忙的伦理会诊服务在二十多年时间里收集的数据。
我们报告了一些纵向研究结果,这些结果显示伦理会诊请求量从1990年的19例显著增长到2013年的551例,以及请求伦理帮助的患者群体发生了重要变化。这些结果包括:(1)来自初级保健提供者(如医生和护士)的请求稳步增长,以及辅助服务(如社会工作者)的请求增加;(2)在请求伦理帮助之前住院时间(天数)减少;(3)个人请求伦理帮助的原因增加;(4)重症监护病房(ICU)以外地区的会诊请求激增;(5)住院期间死亡的患者减少(如存活出院);以及(6)缺乏决策能力的患者数量增加。
我们认为会诊请求的增加反映了适当且必要的增长,因为最近的会诊还与需要(7)额外干预和(8)相当高的时间强度评分的会诊相关。