Jones Vickie E, Karydis Anastasios, Hottel Timothy L
Prof. Jones is Assistant Professor and Administrative Director, Predoctoral Clinical Program in Periodontology, Department of Periodontology, College of Dentistry, University of Tennessee Health Science Center; Dr. Karydis is Associate Professor, Department of Periodontology, College of Dentistry, University of Tennessee Health Science Center; and Dr. Hottel is Professor and Dean, College of Dentistry, University of Tennessee Health Science Center.
J Dent Educ. 2017 Oct;81(10):1203-1212. doi: 10.21815/JDE.017.058.
Interprofessional and intraprofessional education (when students from two or more professions or within the same profession, respectively, learn about, from, and/or with each other) is crucial for effective interdisciplinary collaboration. The aims of this study were to assess the effectiveness of a clinical intraprofessional education program for dental and dental hygiene students, based on students' expectations and satisfaction with the program and patients' satisfaction with the team-based care. The pilot program was developed at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center College of Dentistry, where dental hygiene students were paired randomly with dental students scheduled for prophylaxis, scaling and root planing, or periodontal maintenance. Surveys with questions about the students' expectations and satisfaction were distributed to 89 senior dental students and 27 senior dental hygiene students before and after team-based procedures. Another survey was distributed to 17 patients asking about their satisfaction with the team-based care. All 27 dental hygiene students (100% response rate), 51 dental students (57.3% response rate), and all 17 patients (100% response rate) participated in the surveys. The results showed that both the dental and dental hygiene students had high expectations and were overall satisfied with the intraprofessional education. The students' expectations and perceived educational gap (difference between expectations and satisfaction) differed for the dental and dental hygiene students (p<0.001). The male dental students were also more satisfied than the female dental students (p<0.01). Overall, the program met or exceeded the students' expectations, and the patients were overwhelmingly satisfied with the team-based care. These results suggest that this intraprofessional practice model provided an effective educational experience for both dental and dental hygiene students and patients. The differences between the dental hygiene and dental students' expectations will help in the design of more effective training that promotes intraprofessional and interprofessional teamwork.
跨专业教育和专业内教育(分别指来自两个或更多专业的学生或同一专业内的学生相互学习、相互借鉴和/或相互合作)对于有效的跨学科协作至关重要。本研究的目的是基于学生对该项目的期望和满意度以及患者对团队式护理的满意度,评估一项针对牙科和口腔卫生专业学生的临床专业内教育项目的有效性。该试点项目是在田纳西大学健康科学中心牙科学院开展的,在那里,口腔卫生专业的学生被随机与安排进行预防、洁治和根面平整或牙周维护的牙科学生配对。在团队式操作前后,向89名牙科高年级学生和27名口腔卫生专业高年级学生发放了有关学生期望和满意度的调查问卷。另一项调查问卷发放给了17名患者,询问他们对团队式护理的满意度。所有27名口腔卫生专业学生(回复率100%)、51名牙科学生(回复率57.3%)和所有17名患者(回复率100%)都参与了调查。结果显示,牙科和口腔卫生专业的学生都有很高的期望,并且总体上对专业内教育感到满意。牙科和口腔卫生专业学生的期望以及感知到的教育差距(期望与满意度之间的差异)有所不同(p<0.001)。男性牙科学生也比女性牙科学生更满意(p<0.01)。总体而言,该项目达到或超出了学生的期望,并且患者对团队式护理非常满意。这些结果表明,这种专业内实践模式为牙科和口腔卫生专业的学生以及患者都提供了有效的教育体验。口腔卫生专业学生和牙科学生期望之间的差异将有助于设计更有效的培训,以促进专业内和跨专业团队合作。