Collings Laurel J, Cook Nathan E, Porter Shaun, Kusch Cody, Sun Jonathan, Virji-Babul Naznin, Iverson Grant L, Panenka William J
a Department of Psychiatry , University of British Columbia , Vancouver , Canada.
b Child and Family Research Institute , Vancouver , Canada.
Brain Inj. 2017;31(11):1479-1485. doi: 10.1080/02699052.2017.1377351. Epub 2017 Oct 5.
The objectives of this study were to report baseline, preseason data for the Child-SCAT3, stratified by attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) status, and examine group differences in Child-SCAT3 performance between children with and without ADHD.
Cross-sectional study.
Young male hockey players (n = 304), aged 8-12 years, were administered the Child-SCAT3 during pre-season. Child-SCAT3 measures included a 20-item symptom scale, a Standardised Assessment of Concussion Child Version (SAC-C), a modified Balance Error Scoring System (m-BESS), a tandem gait task, and a coordination test.
Children with ADHD (n = 20) endorsed significantly more symptoms (d = 0.95) and greater symptom severity (d = 1.13) compared to children without ADHD. No statistically significant differences were found between groups on Child-SCAT3 measures of cognitive or physical functioning (e.g. balance and coordination).
ADHD should be considered when interpreting Child-SCAT3 scores, especially symptom reporting, in the context of concussion assessment. Better understanding of symptom reporting in uninjured child athletes with ADHD can inform the clinical interpretation of symptoms at baseline and following an actual or suspected concussion. Normative data for the Child-SCAT3 that is not stratified by or otherwise accounts for ADHD status should be used with caution when appraising performance of children with ADHD.
本研究的目的是报告按注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)状态分层的儿童SCAT3基线、季前数据,并检查患有和未患有ADHD的儿童在儿童SCAT3表现上的组间差异。
横断面研究。
对年龄在8至12岁的年轻男性曲棍球运动员(n = 304)在季前进行儿童SCAT3测试。儿童SCAT3测量包括一个20项症状量表、儿童版脑震荡标准化评估(SAC-C)、改良平衡误差评分系统(m-BESS)、串联步态任务和一项协调测试。
与未患ADHD的儿童相比,患ADHD的儿童(n = 20)认可的症状明显更多(d = 0.95),症状严重程度更高(d = 1.13)。在儿童SCAT3的认知或身体功能测量(如平衡和协调)方面,两组之间未发现统计学上的显著差异。
在脑震荡评估背景下解释儿童SCAT3分数,尤其是症状报告时,应考虑ADHD。更好地了解未受伤的患有ADHD的儿童运动员的症状报告,可以为基线时以及实际或疑似脑震荡后的症状临床解释提供信息。在评估患有ADHD的儿童的表现时,应谨慎使用未按ADHD状态分层或以其他方式考虑ADHD状态的儿童SCAT3的规范数据。