Zhou Kehua, Jia Peng, Bhargava Swati, Zhang Yong, Reza Taslima, Peng Yuan Bo, Wang Gary G
Catholic Health System Internal Medicine Training Program, Sisters of Charity Hospital, University at Buffalo, 2157 Main Street, Buffalo, NY 14214, United States.
Faculty of Geo-information Science and Earth Observation (ITC), University of Twente, Enschede 7500, The Netherlands.
Scand J Pain. 2017 Oct;17:167-173. doi: 10.1016/j.sjpain.2017.09.005. Epub 2017 Oct 5.
Opioid use disorder (OUD) refers to a maladaptive pattern of opioid use leading to clinically significant impairment or distress. OUD causes, and vice versa, misuses and abuse of opioid medications. Clinicians face daily challenges to treat patients with prescription opioid use disorder. An evidence-based management for people who are already addicted to opioids has been identified as the national priority in the US; however, options are limited in clinical practices. In this study, we aimed to explore the success rate and important adjuvant medications in the medication assisted treatment with temporary use of methadone for opioid discontinuation in patients with prescription OUD.
This is a retrospective chart review performed at a private physician office for physical medicine and rehabilitation. We reviewed all medical records dated between December 1st, 2011 and August 30th, 2016. The initial evaluation of the included patients (N=140) was completed between December 1st, 2011 and December 31st, 2014. They all have concumittant prescription OUD and chronic non-cancer pain. The patients (87 female and 53 male) were 46.7±12.7 years old, and had a history of opioid use of 7.7±6.1 years. All patients received the comprehensive opioid taper treatments (including interventional pain management techniques, psychotherapy, acupuncture, physical modalities and exercises, and adjuvant medications) on top of the medication assisted treatment using methadone (transient use). Opioid tapering was considered successful when no opioid medication was used in the last patient visit.
The 140 patients had pain of 9.6±8.4 years with 8/10 intensity before treatment which decreased after treatment in all comparisons (p<0.001 for all). Opioids were successfully tapered off in 39 (27.9%) patients after 6.6±6.7 visits over 8.8±7.2 months; these patients maintained opioid abstinence over 14.3±13.0 months with regular office visits. Among the 101 patients with unsuccessful opioid tapering, 13 patients only visited the outpatient clinic once. Significant differences were found between patients with and without successful opioid tapering in treatment duration, number of clinic visits, the use of mirtazepine, bupropion, topiramate, and trigger point injections with the univariate analyses. The use of mirtazepine (OR, 3.75; 95% CI, 1.48-9.49), topiramate (OR, 5.61; 95% CI, 1.91-16.48), or bupropion (OR, 2.5; 95% CI, 1.08-5.81) was significantly associated with successful opioid tapering. The associations remain significant for mirtazepine and topiramate (not bupropion) in different adjusted models.
With comprehensive treatments, 27.9% of patients had successful opioid tapering with opioid abstinence for over a year. The use of mirtazepine, topiramate, or likely bupropion was associated with successful opioid tapering in the medication assisted treatment with temporary use of methadone. Opioid tapering may be a practical option and should be considered for managing prescription OUD.
For patients with OUD, indefinite opioid maintenance treatment may not be necessary. Considering the ethical values of autonomy, nonmaleficence, and beneficence, clinicians should provide patients with OUD the option of opioid tapering.
阿片类物质使用障碍(OUD)是指阿片类物质使用的适应不良模式,导致临床上显著的损害或痛苦。OUD引发阿片类药物的滥用和误用,反之亦然。临床医生在治疗处方阿片类物质使用障碍患者时每天都面临挑战。在美国,为已对阿片类物质成瘾者制定循证管理方法已被确定为国家优先事项;然而,临床实践中的选择有限。在本研究中,我们旨在探讨在使用美沙酮临时停药辅助治疗处方OUD患者时,阿片类物质停用的成功率及重要辅助药物。
这是一项在一家私人物理医学与康复医生办公室进行的回顾性病历审查。我们查阅了2011年12月1日至2016年8月30日期间的所有病历。纳入患者(N = 140)的初始评估于2011年12月1日至2014年12月31日完成。他们均患有处方OUD和慢性非癌性疼痛。患者(87名女性和53名男性)年龄为46.7±12.7岁,阿片类物质使用史为7.7±6.1年。所有患者在使用美沙酮(临时使用)辅助治疗的基础上,接受了全面的阿片类物质减量治疗(包括介入性疼痛管理技术、心理治疗、针灸、物理治疗和锻炼以及辅助药物)。当最后一次就诊未使用阿片类药物时,阿片类物质减量被视为成功。
140例患者治疗前疼痛9.6±8.4年,强度为8/10,所有比较中治疗后均降低(所有p<0.001)。39例(27.9%)患者在8.8±7.2个月内经过6.6±6.7次就诊后成功停用阿片类物质;这些患者通过定期门诊就诊在14.3±13.0个月内保持阿片类物质戒断。在101例阿片类物质减量未成功的患者中,13例仅门诊就诊过一次。单因素分析发现,阿片类物质减量成功与未成功的患者在治疗持续时间、门诊就诊次数、米氮平、安非他酮、托吡酯的使用以及触发点注射方面存在显著差异。米氮平(OR,3.75;95%CI,1.48 - 9.49)、托吡酯(OR,5.61;95%CI,1.91 - 16.48)或安非他酮(OR,2.5;95%CI,1.08 - 5.81)的使用与阿片类物质减量成功显著相关。在不同的校正模型中,米氮平和托吡酯(而非安非他酮)的相关性仍然显著。
通过综合治疗,27.9%的患者成功停用阿片类物质并保持阿片类物质戒断超过一年。在使用美沙酮临时停药辅助治疗中,米氮平、托吡酯或可能的安非他酮的使用与阿片类物质减量成功相关。阿片类物质减量可能是一种可行的选择,在管理处方OUD时应予以考虑。
对于OUD患者,可能无需无限期的阿片类物质维持治疗。考虑到自主性、不伤害和有益的伦理价值,临床医生应为OUD患者提供阿片类物质减量的选择。