Groothuis Jitte, Smid Hans M
Laboratory of Entomology, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Brain Behav Evol. 2017;90(3):243-254. doi: 10.1159/000480421. Epub 2017 Oct 24.
Haller's rule states that brains scale allometrically with body size in all animals, meaning that relative brain size increases with decreasing body size. This rule applies both on inter- and intraspecific comparisons. Only 1 species, the extremely small parasitic wasp Trichogramma evanescens, is known as an exception and shows an isometric brain-body size relation in an intraspecific comparison between differently sized individuals. Here, we investigated if such an isometric brain-body size relationship also occurs in an intraspecific comparison with a slightly larger parasitic wasp, Nasonia vitripennis, a species that may vary 10-fold in body weight upon differences in levels of scramble competition during larval development. We show that Nasonia exhibits diphasic brain-body size scaling: larger wasps scale allometrically, following Haller's rule, whereas the smallest wasps show isometric scaling. Brains of smaller wasps are, therefore, smaller than expected and we hypothesized that this may lead to adaptations in brain architecture. Volumetric analysis of neuropil composition revealed that wasps of different sizes differed in relative volume of multiple neuropils. The optic lobes and mushroom bodies in particular were smaller in the smallest wasps. Furthermore, smaller brains had a relatively smaller total neuropil volume and larger cellular rind than large brains. These changes in relative brain size and brain architecture suggest that the energetic constraints on brain tissue outweigh specific cognitive requirements in small Nasonia wasps.
哈勒法则指出,在所有动物中,大脑与身体大小呈异速生长比例关系,这意味着相对脑容量会随着身体尺寸的减小而增加。该法则适用于种间和种内比较。只有1个物种,即极小的寄生蜂赤眼蜂,被认为是个例外,在不同大小个体的种内比较中,其脑体大小呈现等比例关系。在此,我们研究了在与稍大的寄生蜂丽蝇蛹集金小蜂的种内比较中,是否也会出现这种脑体大小的等比例关系。丽蝇蛹集金小蜂在幼虫发育期间,由于争夺竞争程度的差异,体重可能相差10倍。我们发现,丽蝇蛹集金小蜂呈现双相脑体大小比例关系:较大的黄蜂遵循哈勒法则,呈异速生长比例关系,而最小的黄蜂则呈现等比例关系。因此,较小黄蜂的大脑比预期的要小,我们推测这可能导致大脑结构的适应性变化。对神经纤维网组成的体积分析表明,不同大小的黄蜂在多个神经纤维网的相对体积上存在差异。特别是最小的黄蜂的视叶和蘑菇体较小。此外,较小的大脑与较大的大脑相比,其总的神经纤维网体积相对较小,而细胞外皮较大。相对脑容量和大脑结构的这些变化表明,对于小型丽蝇蛹集金小蜂而言,脑组织的能量限制超过了特定的认知需求。