Department of Radiation Oncology, Brigham & Woman's Hospital, Dana Farber Cancer Institute and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Department of Physics and Applied Physics, Medical Physics Program, University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, MA, USA.
Med Phys. 2017 Dec;44(12):6632-6640. doi: 10.1002/mp.12636. Epub 2017 Nov 13.
We developed a method for measuring signal enhancement produced by high-Z nanofilm electrodes in parallel plate ionization chambers with variable thickness microgaps.
We used a laboratory-made variable gap parallel plate ionization chamber with nanofilm electrodes made of aluminum-aluminum (Al-Al) and aluminum-tantalum (Al-Ta). The electrodes were evaporated on 1 mm thick glass substrates. The interelectrode air gap was varied from 3 μm to 1 cm. The gap size was measured using a digital micrometer and it was confirmed by capacitance measurements. The electric field in the chamber was kept between 0.1 kV/cm and 1 kV/cm for all the gap sizes by applying appropriate compensating voltages. The chamber was exposed to 120 kVp X-rays. The current was measured using a commercial data acquisition system with temporal resolution of 600 Hz. In addition, radiation transport simulations were carried out to characterize the dose, D(x), high-energy electron current, J(x), and deposited charge, Q(x), as a function of distance, x, from the electrodes. A deterministic method was selected over Monte Carlo due to its ability to produce results with 10 nm spatial resolution without stochastic uncertainties. Experimental signal enhancement ratio, SER(G) which we defined as the ratio of signal for Al-air-Ta to signal for Al-air-Al for each gap size, was compared to computations. The individual contributions of dose, electron current, and charge deposition to the signal enhancement were determined.
Experimental signals matched computed data for all gap sizes after accounting for several contributions to the signal: (a) charge carrier generated via ionization due to the energy deposited in the air gap, D(x); (b) high-energy electron current, J(x), leaking from high-Z electrode (Ta) toward low-Z electrode (Al); (c) deposited charge in the air gap, Q(x); and (d) the decreased collection efficiency for large gaps (>~500 μm). Q(x) accounts for the electrons below 100 eV, which are regarded as stopped by the radiation transport code but which can move and form electron current in small gaps (<100 μm). While the total energy deposited in the air gap increases with gap size for both samples, the average high-energy current and deposited charge are moderately decreasing with the air gap. When gap sizes are smaller than ~20 μm, the contribution to signal from dose approaches zero while contributions from high-energy current and deposited charges give rise to an offset signal. The measured signal enhancement ratio (SER) was 40.0 ± 5.0 for the 3 μm gap and rapidly decreasing with gap size down to 9.9 ± 1.2 for the 21 μm gap and to 6.6 ± 0.3 for the 100 μm gap. The uncertainties in SER were mostly due to uncertainties in gap size and data acquisition system.
We developed an experimental method to determine the signal enhancement due to high-Z nanolayers in parallel plate ionization chambers with micrometer spatial resolution. As the water-equivalent thicknesses of these air gaps are 3 nm to 10 μm, the method may also be applicable for nanoscopic spatial resolution of other gap materials. The method may be extended to solid insulator materials with low Z.
我们开发了一种测量具有可变微间隙的平行板电离室中高 Z 纳米薄膜电极产生的信号增强的方法。
我们使用实验室制造的带有纳米薄膜电极的可变间隙平行板电离室,电极由铝-铝(Al-Al)和铝-钽(Al-Ta)制成。电极蒸发在 1mm 厚的玻璃衬底上。电极之间的气隙从 3μm 变化到 1cm。使用数字千分尺测量间隙尺寸,并通过电容测量进行验证。为了使所有间隙尺寸的电场都保持在 0.1kV/cm 至 1kV/cm,通过施加适当的补偿电压。该室暴露于 120kVp X 射线。使用具有 600Hz 时间分辨率的商用数据采集系统测量电流。此外,还进行了辐射传输模拟,以表征剂量、D(x)、高能电子电流、J(x)和从电极沉积的电荷、Q(x)作为距离、x 的函数。由于其能够在没有随机不确定性的情况下以 10nm 的空间分辨率生成结果,因此选择了确定性方法而不是蒙特卡罗方法。我们定义的实验信号增强比 SER(G)为每个间隙尺寸的 Al-空气-Ta 信号与 Al-空气-Al 信号的比值,与计算结果进行了比较。确定了剂量、电子电流和电荷沉积对信号增强的单独贡献。
在考虑了对信号的几种贡献后,所有间隙尺寸的实验信号都与计算数据匹配:(a) 由于在气隙中沉积的能量,在空气中产生的载流子由于电离而产生;(b) 从高 Z 电极(Ta)泄漏到低 Z 电极(Al)的高能电子电流;(c) 气隙中的沉积电荷;(d) 较大间隙(>500μm)的收集效率降低。Q(x) 表示低于 100eV 的电子,这些电子被辐射传输代码视为被阻止,但在小间隙(<100μm)中可以移动并形成电子电流。虽然两个样本中空气间隙中沉积的总能量随间隙尺寸增加,但平均高能电流和沉积电荷适度减小。当间隙尺寸小于20μm 时,来自剂量的信号贡献接近零,而来自高能电流和沉积电荷的贡献则产生偏移信号。测量的信号增强比(SER)在 3μm 间隙时为 40.0±5.0,随着间隙尺寸迅速减小到 21μm 间隙时为 9.9±1.2,到 100μm 间隙时为 6.6±0.3。SER 的不确定性主要是由于间隙尺寸和数据采集系统的不确定性。
我们开发了一种实验方法,用于确定平行板电离室中高 Z 纳米层产生的信号增强,具有微米级的空间分辨率。由于这些气隙的水等效厚度为 3nm 至 10μm,因此该方法也可适用于其他气隙材料的纳米级空间分辨率。该方法可以扩展到具有低 Z 的固体绝缘体材料。