Department of Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
Department of Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
Surgery. 2018 Apr;163(4):801-806. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2017.10.012. Epub 2017 Nov 22.
It has been suggested that accurate clinical decisions may be made in patients with primary aldosteronism (PA) in the setting of failed cannulation of an adrenal vein, thereby utilizing only data from either right or left adrenal venous sampling (AVS) alone.
Retrospective analysis was performed for all patients with PA who underwent successful bilateral AVS. Adrenal vein/inferior vena cava index (AV/IVC index) was calculated by dividing aldosterone/cortisol ratio of the adrenal vein by aldosterone/cortisol ratio in the inferior vena cava, as described in a previously published study. We examined the rates of inappropriate adrenalectomy and failure to recognize unilateral disease when previously published cutoffs are used.
Inclusion criteria were met in 150 patients; 61 with bilateral and 89 with unilateral disease. AV/IVC index cutoff of ≤0.5 to predict contralateral disease would have not led to any inappropriate adrenalectomies and would have missed 19% of patients with unilateral disease; AV/IVC index cutoff of ≥5.5 to predict ipsilateral unilateral disease would have resulted in inappropriate adrenalectomy in 18% of patients (95% CI 8-34%, P < .01) and would have not recognized 55% of patients with unilateral disease (P < .01).
The cortisol-corrected adrenal vein/inferior vena cava aldosterone index with a cutoff value of ≤0.5 performed well in identifying patients with contralateral unilateral disease. AV/IVC index of ≥5.5 cannot be used to reliably diagnose ipsilateral unilateral disease because 18% of patients undergoing adrenalectomy based on this cutoff would have bilateral disease.
有人提出,在肾上腺静脉插管失败的情况下,通过仅利用单侧肾上腺静脉采样(AVS)的数据,可能可以对原发性醛固酮增多症(PA)患者做出准确的临床决策。
对所有成功进行双侧 AVS 的 PA 患者进行回顾性分析。如先前发表的研究所述,通过将肾上腺静脉中醛固酮/皮质醇比值除以下腔静脉中醛固酮/皮质醇比值,计算出肾上腺静脉/下腔静脉指数(AV/IVC 指数)。我们检查了使用先前发表的切点时,单侧疾病识别失败和不适当肾上腺切除术的发生率。
符合纳入标准的患者有 150 例,双侧疾病 61 例,单侧疾病 89 例。如果使用≤0.5 的 AV/IVC 指数切点来预测对侧疾病,将不会导致任何不适当的肾上腺切除术,并且会漏诊 19%的单侧疾病患者;如果使用≥5.5 的 AV/IVC 指数切点来预测同侧单侧疾病,将导致 18%的患者(95%CI 8-34%,P<0.01)进行不适当的肾上腺切除术,并且会漏诊 55%的单侧疾病患者(P<0.01)。
用切点值≤0.5 的校正皮质醇的肾上腺静脉/下腔静脉醛固酮指数可以很好地识别出对侧单侧疾病患者。AV/IVC 指数≥5.5 不能用于可靠地诊断同侧单侧疾病,因为基于此切点值进行肾上腺切除术的 18%的患者可能患有双侧疾病。