Zacchino Susana A, Butassi Estefanía, Cordisco Estefanía, Svetaz Laura A
Área Farmacognosia, Facultad de Ciencias Bioquímicas y Farmacéuticas, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Suipacha 531, 2000 Rosario, Argentina.
Área Farmacognosia, Facultad de Ciencias Bioquímicas y Farmacéuticas, Universidad Nacional de Rosario, Suipacha 531, 2000 Rosario, Argentina.
Phytomedicine. 2017 Dec 15;37:14-26. doi: 10.1016/j.phymed.2017.10.021. Epub 2017 Nov 23.
Biofilms contribute to the pathogenesis of many chronic and difficult-to eradicate infections whose treatment is complicated due to the intrinsic resistance to conventional antibiotics. As a consequence, there is an urgent need for strategies that can be used for the prevention and treatment of biofilm-associated infections. The combination therapy comprising an antimicrobial drug with a low molecular weight (MW) natural product and an antimicrobial drug (antifungal or antibacterial) appeared as a good alternative to eradicate biofilms.
The aims of this review were to perform a literature search on the different natural products that have showed the ability of potentiating the antibiofilm capacity of antimicrobial drugs, to analyze which are the antimicrobial drugs most used in combination, and to have a look on the microbial species most used to prepare biofilms.
Seventeen papers, nine on combinations against antifungal biofilms and eight against antibacterial biofilms were collected. Within the text, the following topics have been developed: breaf history of the discovery of biofilms; stages in the development of a biofilm; the most used methodologies to assess antibiofilm-activity; the natural products with capacity of eradicating biofilms when acting alone; the combinations of low MW natural products with antibiotics or antifungal drugs as a strategy for eradicating microbial biofilms and a list of the low MW natural products that potentiate the inhibition capacity of antifungal and antibacterial drugs against biofilms.
Regarding combinations against antifungal biofilms, eight over the nine collected works were carried out with in vitro studies while only one was performed with in vivo assays by using Caenorhabditis elegans nematode. All studies use biofilms of the Candida genus. A 67% of the potentiators were monoterpenes and sesquiterpenes and six over the nine works used FCZ as the antifungal drug. The activity of AmpB and Caspo was enhanced in one and two works respectively. Regarding combinations against bacterial biofilms, in vitro studies were performed in all works by using several different methods of higher variety than the used against fungal biofilms. Biofilms of both the gram (+) and gram (-) bacteria were prepared, although biofilm of Staphylococcus spp. were the most used in the collected works. Among the discovered potentiators of antibacterial drugs, 75% were terpenes, including mono, di- and triterpenes, and, among the atibacterial drugs, several structurally diverse types were used in the combinations: aminoglycosides, β-lactams, glucopeptides and fluoroquinolones. The potentiating capacity of natural products, mainly terpenes, on the antibiofilm effect of antimicrobial drugs opens a wide range of possibilities for the combination antimicrobial therapy. More in vivo studies on combinations of natural products with antimicrobial drugs acting against biofilms are highly required to cope the difficult to treat biofilm-associated infections.
生物膜导致许多慢性且难以根除的感染发病,由于其对传统抗生素具有内在抗性,这些感染的治疗变得复杂。因此,迫切需要可用于预防和治疗生物膜相关感染的策略。包含低分子量(MW)天然产物和抗菌药物(抗真菌或抗菌)的联合疗法似乎是根除生物膜的良好替代方案。
本综述的目的是对已显示出增强抗菌药物抗生物膜能力的不同天然产物进行文献检索,分析联合使用最多的抗菌药物,以及了解用于制备生物膜的最常用微生物种类。
收集了17篇论文,其中9篇针对抗真菌生物膜的联合研究,8篇针对抗细菌生物膜的联合研究。在本文中,探讨了以下主题:生物膜发现的简要历史;生物膜形成的阶段;评估抗生物膜活性最常用的方法;单独作用时具有根除生物膜能力的天然产物;低分子量天然产物与抗生素或抗真菌药物的联合使用作为根除微生物生物膜的策略,以及增强抗真菌和抗菌药物对生物膜抑制能力的低分子量天然产物列表。
关于抗真菌生物膜的联合研究,9篇已收集的论文中有8篇是体外研究,只有1篇是通过使用秀丽隐杆线虫进行体内试验。所有研究均使用念珠菌属生物膜。67%的增效剂是单萜和倍半萜,9篇论文中有6篇使用氟康唑作为抗真菌药物。分别在1篇和2篇论文中增强了两性霉素B和卡泊芬净的活性。关于抗细菌生物膜的联合研究,所有研究均为体外研究,使用的方法比抗真菌生物膜研究中使用的方法更多样化。制备了革兰氏(+)和革兰氏(-)细菌的生物膜,尽管金黄色葡萄球菌属生物膜是已收集论文中最常用的。在已发现的抗菌药物增效剂中,75%是萜类,包括单萜、二萜和三萜,并且在联合使用的抗菌药物中,使用了几种结构不同类型的药物:氨基糖苷类、β-内酰胺类、糖肽类和氟喹诺酮类。天然产物(主要是萜类)对抗菌药物抗生物膜作用的增效能力为联合抗菌治疗开辟了广泛的可能性。迫切需要更多关于天然产物与抗生物膜抗菌药物联合使用的体内研究,以应对难以治疗的生物膜相关感染。