Cole Casey A, Anshari Dien, Lambert Victoria, Thrasher James F, Valafar Homayoun
Computational Biology Research Group, Department of Computer Science, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC, United States.
Department of Health Promotion, Education & Behavior, Arnold School of Public Health, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC, United States.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2017 Dec 13;5(12):e189. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.9035.
Smoking is the leading cause of preventable death in the world today. Ecological research on smoking in context currently relies on self-reported smoking behavior. Emerging smartwatch technology may more objectively measure smoking behavior by automatically detecting smoking sessions using robust machine learning models.
This study aimed to examine the feasibility of detecting smoking behavior using smartwatches. The second aim of this study was to compare the success of observing smoking behavior with smartwatches to that of conventional self-reporting.
A convenience sample of smokers was recruited for this study. Participants (N=10) recorded 12 hours of accelerometer data using a mobile phone and smartwatch. During these 12 hours, they engaged in various daily activities, including smoking, for which they logged the beginning and end of each smoking session. Raw data were classified as either smoking or nonsmoking using a machine learning model for pattern recognition. The accuracy of the model was evaluated by comparing the output with a detailed description of a modeled smoking session.
In total, 120 hours of data were collected from participants and analyzed. The accuracy of self-reported smoking was approximately 78% (96/123). Our model was successful in detecting 100 of 123 (81%) smoking sessions recorded by participants. After eliminating sessions from the participants that did not adhere to study protocols, the true positive detection rate of the smartwatch based-detection increased to more than 90%. During the 120 hours of combined observation time, only 22 false positive smoking sessions were detected resulting in a 2.8% false positive rate.
Smartwatch technology can provide an accurate, nonintrusive means of monitoring smoking behavior in natural contexts. The use of machine learning algorithms for passively detecting smoking sessions may enrich ecological momentary assessment protocols and cessation intervention studies that often rely on self-reported behaviors and may not allow for targeted data collection and communications around smoking events.
吸烟是当今世界可预防死亡的首要原因。目前关于吸烟的环境生态学研究依赖于自我报告的吸烟行为。新兴的智能手表技术可能通过使用强大的机器学习模型自动检测吸烟时段,从而更客观地测量吸烟行为。
本研究旨在检验使用智能手表检测吸烟行为的可行性。本研究的第二个目的是比较使用智能手表观察吸烟行为与传统自我报告的成功率。
本研究招募了一个吸烟者便利样本。参与者(N = 10)使用手机和智能手表记录了12小时的加速度计数据。在这12小时内,他们进行了各种日常活动,包括吸烟,他们记录了每次吸烟时段的开始和结束。使用模式识别机器学习模型将原始数据分类为吸烟或不吸烟。通过将输出与模拟吸烟时段的详细描述进行比较来评估模型的准确性。
总共从参与者那里收集并分析了120小时的数据。自我报告吸烟的准确率约为78%(96/123)。我们的模型成功检测到了参与者记录的123个吸烟时段中的100个(81%)。在排除未遵守研究方案的参与者的时段后,基于智能手表检测的真阳性率提高到了90%以上。在120小时的联合观察时间内,仅检测到22个假阳性吸烟时段,假阳性率为2.8%。
智能手表技术可以提供一种准确、非侵入性的方法来监测自然环境中的吸烟行为。使用机器学习算法被动检测吸烟时段可能会丰富生态瞬时评估方案和戒烟干预研究,这些研究通常依赖于自我报告的行为,可能无法实现围绕吸烟事件的有针对性的数据收集和沟通。