Velz Julia, Bozinov Oliver, Sarnthein Johannes, Regli Luca, Bellut David
Department of Neurosurgery, Clinical Neuroscience Center, University Hospital Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
J Neurosurg Sci. 2018 Aug;62(4):383-396. doi: 10.23736/S0390-5616.18.04305-9. Epub 2018 Jan 4.
Spinal cavernous malformations (SCM) were once thought to be rare lesions of the spinal cord. However, with the broad use of modern imaging techniques the incidence of SCM has significantly increased over the last decades. Management of both symptomatic and incidental findings is therefore of growing importance. However, experience with treatment and follow-up is very limited.
We performed a single institution retrospective review of consecutive patients with SCM treated at our Department between 2006-2016 and discuss the clinical features as well as surgical versus conservative outcomes. We further provide a systematic literature search and discuss the best management of SCM, analyzing recent publications on SCM imaging techniques, surgical approaches and natural history.
From a total number of 406 consecutive patients with cavernous malformations (CM) treated at our Department between 2006-2016, 29 (7.1%) were found to be affected by SCM. The localization was cervical in 10 (34.5%), cervicothoracic in 3 (10.4%) and thoracic in 16 (55.2%) patients. In 90% of patients (N.=26) the diagnosis was made after onset of clinical symptoms. Conservative management was performed for 8 patients, whereas 21 patients underwent surgical removal of the lesion via a posterior approach using (hemi-) laminectomy or laminoplasty. Functional status improved in 15 patients (62.5%) and remained unchanged in 6 patients (28.5%) in the operative group, whereas 2 patients (25%) improved and 6 patients (75%) remained unchanged in the conservative group during long-term follow-up.
Gross-total resection is the only definitive treatment option for symptomatic SCM. Surgical extirpation of the symptomatic SCM lesion through an unilateral laminectomy (=hemilaminectomy) approach within 3 months of presentation seems to be good treatment option with an acceptable risk of complications and good long-term outcomes. Conservative treatment should be performed in asymptomatic patients and seems to be an option as well in elderly patients and if patients' symptoms at diagnosis are mild and do not show progression over time.
脊髓海绵状血管畸形(SCM)曾被认为是脊髓的罕见病变。然而,随着现代成像技术的广泛应用,在过去几十年中SCM的发病率显著增加。因此,对有症状和偶然发现的病变进行管理变得越来越重要。然而,治疗和随访经验非常有限。
我们对2006年至2016年在我院接受治疗的连续性SCM患者进行了单机构回顾性研究,并讨论了临床特征以及手术与保守治疗的结果。我们还进行了系统的文献检索,并讨论了SCM的最佳管理方法,分析了最近关于SCM成像技术、手术方法和自然史的出版物。
在2006年至2016年期间我院治疗的406例连续性海绵状血管畸形(CM)患者中,发现29例(7.1%)患有SCM。病变部位为颈椎的有10例(34.5%),颈胸段的有3例(10.4%),胸椎的有16例(55.2%)。90%的患者(n = 26)在出现临床症状后确诊。8例患者接受了保守治疗,而21例患者通过后路(半)椎板切除术或椎板成形术手术切除了病变。在手术组中,15例患者(62.5%)功能状态改善,6例患者(28.5%)保持不变;而在保守治疗组中,长期随访期间2例患者(25%)改善,6例患者(75%)保持不变。
对于有症状的SCM,全切除是唯一的确定性治疗选择。在出现症状后3个月内通过单侧椎板切除术(即半椎板切除术)手术切除有症状的SCM病变似乎是一个不错的治疗选择,并发症风险可接受,长期效果良好。对于无症状患者应进行保守治疗,对于老年患者以及诊断时症状轻微且未随时间进展的患者,保守治疗似乎也是一种选择。