a Department of Rehabilitation, Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour , Radboud University Medical Center , Nijmegen , The Netherlands.
b Department of Occupational Therapy , HAN University of Applied Sciences , Nijmegen , The Netherlands.
Disabil Rehabil. 2019 Jun;41(12):1427-1434. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2018.1430175. Epub 2018 Jan 31.
There is lack of knowledge, evidence, and guidelines for rehabilitation interventions for persons with neuralgic amyotrophy (NA) or brachial plexus pathology. A first pilot study, evaluating the effect of an integrated rehabilitation programme, showed improvements in activity and participation levels.
To gain insight, from the perspective of patients and therapists, into the critical ingredients of the programme, that contributed to improvements in activity and participation.
A qualitative study using semi-structured interviews with eight patients and five therapists (three occupational therapists and two physical therapists). Participants were asked to identify and describe factors regarding the rehabilitation that they perceived as positive and aspects of the programme that could be improved. Data were analysed using a constant comparative approach.
Patients reported (1) Time to diagnose: "Finally I'm in the right place;" (2) Awareness: "They gave me a mirror;" (3) Partnership: "There was real contact with the therapists; we made decisions together;" (4) Close collaboration: "Overlapping scopes of practice; doing the same from a different perspective;" and finally (5) Self-management: "Now I can do it myself." Therapists reported (1) "Patients knowledge and understanding is critical to success;" (2) "Activate problem solving and decision making;" (3) "Personalize your therapy; it's more than just giving exercises and information;" (4) "Constant consultation within the team; consistency in messages and approach;" and (5)" Ultimately the patient is in charge."
The critical ingredients, correspond well with each other and include a person-centred approach, education, support in problem solving and decision making and an integrated team approach. These ingredients provided the patients with confidence to take responsibility to manage their everyday lives, the ultimate goal of the programme. Implications for rehabilitation Both patients and therapists believe that the ability to self-manage and take control should be the outcome of high quality integrated rehabilitation programmes for patients with neuralgic amyotrophy and/or other brachial plexus injuries. A person-centred, collaborative, and integrated team approach, among all members of the team, are critical components of care delivery in personalised interventions. Critical programme ingredients are knowledge and education of both the patient and therapists; partnership between patient-therapist and within the team; patient activation and self-reflection; and personalised care. Patients recommend more options for personalisation of the intensity and duration of rehabilitation, the possibility to consult a psychologist and peer support within a group setting.
对于神经痛性肌萎缩(NA)或臂丛神经病变患者,康复干预措施缺乏相关知识、证据和指南。一项初步的试点研究评估了综合康复方案的效果,结果显示活动和参与水平有所提高。
从患者和治疗师的角度深入了解方案的关键要素,这些要素有助于提高活动和参与水平。
采用半结构式访谈对 8 名患者和 5 名治疗师(3 名作业治疗师和 2 名物理治疗师)进行定性研究。要求参与者识别和描述他们认为对康复有积极影响的因素以及方案中可以改进的方面。使用恒定比较方法进行数据分析。
患者报告:(1)诊断时间:“终于来对地方了”;(2)意识:“他们给了我一面镜子”;(3)合作关系:“与治疗师有真正的接触;我们一起做决定”;(4)密切合作:“重叠的实践范围;从不同角度做同样的事情”;最后(5)自我管理:“现在我可以自己做了。”治疗师报告:(1)“患者的知识和理解对成功至关重要”;(2)“激活问题解决和决策”;(3)“个性化治疗;不仅仅是提供锻炼和信息”;(4)“团队内持续咨询;信息和方法保持一致”;和(5)“最终由患者负责。”
关键要素相互对应,包括以患者为中心的方法、教育、支持问题解决和决策以及综合团队方法。这些要素使患者有信心承担管理日常生活的责任,这是方案的最终目标。康复意义 患者和治疗师都认为,自我管理和控制能力应该是神经痛性肌萎缩和/或其他臂丛神经损伤患者高质量综合康复方案的结果。以患者为中心、协作和综合团队方法是个性化干预中团队所有成员提供护理的关键组成部分。关键方案要素包括患者和治疗师的知识和教育;患者-治疗师之间以及团队内部的伙伴关系;患者的激活和自我反思;以及个性化护理。患者建议为康复的强度和持续时间提供更多个性化选择的可能性、咨询心理学家和在小组环境中获得同伴支持。