A classification system for verifying the long-term efficacy of resective surgery for drug-resistant seizures.

OBJECTIVE

To verify the long-term efficacy of resective surgery, we created a classification system in which strictly defined patterns of postoperative seizure emergence are incorporated as basic components and the seizure states throughout the entire follow-up period are assessed comprehensively.

METHODS

In our system, Class I has three subclasses (A-C); subclasses A and B are identical to Engel I-A and I-B, respectively. Subclass C comprises patients whose disabling seizures remit within the first 2 years postoperatively. Patients in Class II have only 1-3 days with disabling seizures throughout follow-up after the first 2 years. Patients in Class III have a maximum of 3 seizure days annually, and those in Class IV have ≥4 seizure days annually after the first 2 years. Classes II-IV each have 2 subclasses (A and B): subclass A, late recurrence (i.e., the first seizure occurs after 2 years postoperatively); and subclass B, early recurrence (i.e., first seizure within 2 years). In 646 patients who underwent resective surgery (temporal lobe resection, 74.6%) and were followed for at least 8 years (mean, 14.6 years), we analyzed three patterns of postoperative seizures: early remission, late recurrence, and occasional seizures. In addition, we investigated the differences between the long-term seizure outcomes of the cohort as determined according to our system and the Engel scale.

RESULTS

Overall, 52.9% of the cohort experienced at least one disabling seizure postoperatively throughout the follow-up period; in 1/3 of these patients, the first seizure occurred after 2 years. In 73.8% of the 80 patients who manifested the running-down phenomenon, seizure remission occurred within the first 2 years. In addition, 36.7% of the 283 patients who had disabling seizures after 2 years experienced only 1-3 seizure days. Engel Class I-C included about 30% of the patients who had ≥4 seizure days after 2 years. The long-term seizure outcomes, determined according to our system, were: Class I, 56.2% (C, 9.1%) of the overall cohort; Class II, 16.1% (A, 11.0%); and Class III/IV, 27.7% (A, 6.6%).

CONCLUSION

Our system clarifies the actual effect of resective surgery more precisely than the Engel scale and thus may be useful for comparing outcomes between different surgical procedures or for identifying potential risk factors predicting unfavorable outcome.