Liu Y S, Li Z, Zhao Y J, Ye H Q, Zhou Y Q, Hu W J, Liu Y S, Xun C L, Zhou Y S
Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology & National Engineering Laboratory for Digital and Material Technology of Stomatology & Beijing Key Laboratory of Digital Stomatology, Beijing 100081, China; Second Clinical Division, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology, Beijing 100101, China.
Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology & National Engineering Laboratory for Digital and Material Technology of Stomatology & Beijing Key Laboratory of Digital Stomatology, Beijing 100081, China.
Beijing Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban. 2018 Feb 18;50(1):78-84.
To develop a digital workflow of orthodontic-prosthodontic multidisciplinary treatment plan which can be applied in complicated anterior teeth esthetic rehabilitation, in order to enhance the efficiency of communication between dentists and patients, and improve the predictability of treatment outcome.
Twenty patients with the potential needs of orthodontic-prosthodontic multidisciplinary treatment to solve their complicated esthetic problems in anterior teeth were recruited in this study. Digital models of patients' both dental arches and soft tissues were captured using intra oral scanner. Direct prosthodontic (DP) treatment plan and orthodontic-prosthodontic (OP) treatment plan were carried out for each patient. For DP treatment plans, digital wax-up models were directly designed on original digital models using prosthodontic design system. For OP treatment plans, virtual-setups were performed using orthodontic analyze system according to orthodontic and esthetic criteria and imported to prosthodontic design system to finalize the digital wax-up models. These two treatment plans were shown to the patients and demonstrated elaborately. Each patient rated two treatment plans using visual analogue scales and the medians of scores of two treatment plans were analyzed using signed Wilcoxon test. Having taken into consideration various related factors, including time, costs of treatment, each patient chose a specific treatment plan. For the patients chose DP treatment plans, digital wax-up models were exported and printed into resin diagnostic models which would be utilized in the prosthodontic treatment process. For the patients chose OP treatment plans, virtual-setups were used to fabricate aligners or indirect bonding templates and digital wax-up models were also exported and printed into resin diagnostic models for prosthodontic treatment after orthodontic treatment completed.
The medians of scores of DP treatment plan and OP treatment plan were calculated and analyzed by IBM SPSS 20. The median of scores of DP treatment plan was 8.4, the minimum value was 6.9 and the maximum value was 9.3. The median of scores of OP treatment plan was 9.0, the minimum value was 7.9 and the maximum value was 9.6. The median of scores of OP was significantly higher than that of DP (Z=-3.23, P<0.01). Finally, 12 patients chose OP treatment plans and 8 patients chose DP treatment plans.
For cases with complex esthetic problems in anterior teeth, a digital workflow can demonstrate final treatment outcome and help patients make suitable treatment decisions. In our study, the orthodontic-prosthodontic multidisciplinary treatment plan is feasible which can provide predictions of treatment outcome and improve esthetic outcome with patients' satisfaction.
开发一种可应用于复杂前牙美学修复的正畸 - 修复多学科治疗计划的数字化工作流程,以提高牙医与患者之间的沟通效率,并提高治疗结果的可预测性。
本研究招募了20例有正畸 - 修复多学科治疗潜在需求以解决其复杂前牙美学问题的患者。使用口腔内扫描仪获取患者牙弓和软组织的数字模型。为每位患者制定直接修复(DP)治疗计划和正畸 - 修复(OP)治疗计划。对于DP治疗计划,使用修复设计系统在原始数字模型上直接设计数字蜡型模型。对于OP治疗计划,根据正畸和美学标准使用正畸分析系统进行虚拟排牙,并导入修复设计系统以完成数字蜡型模型。将这两种治疗计划展示给患者并进行详细演示。每位患者使用视觉模拟量表对两种治疗计划进行评分,并使用符号秩和检验分析两种治疗计划得分的中位数。考虑到包括时间、治疗成本等各种相关因素,每位患者选择一种特定的治疗计划。对于选择DP治疗计划的患者,将数字蜡型模型导出并打印成树脂诊断模型,用于修复治疗过程。对于选择OP治疗计划的患者,使用虚拟排牙制作矫治器或间接粘接模板,正畸治疗完成后,数字蜡型模型也导出并打印成树脂诊断模型用于修复治疗。
使用IBM SPSS 20计算并分析DP治疗计划和OP治疗计划得分的中位数。DP治疗计划得分的中位数为8.4,最小值为6.9,最大值为9.3。OP治疗计划得分的中位数为9.0,最小值为7.9,最大值为9.6。OP得分的中位数显著高于DP(Z = -3.23,P < 0.01)。最后,12例患者选择OP治疗计划,8例患者选择DP治疗计划。
对于前牙复杂美学问题的病例,数字化工作流程可以展示最终治疗结果并帮助患者做出合适的治疗决策。在我们的研究中,正畸 - 修复多学科治疗计划是可行的,它可以提供治疗结果的预测并提高美学效果,使患者满意。