Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, 30602, USA.
Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, 30602, USA.
J Environ Manage. 2018 May 1;213:374-381. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2018.02.045.
Forestry Best Management Practices (BMPs) are critical in ensuring sustainable forest management in the United States because of their effectiveness in protecting water quality, reducing soil erosion, maintaining riparian habitat, and sustaining site productivity. The success of forestry BMPs depends heavily on coordination among primary stakeholder groups. It is important to understand perceptions of such groups for a successful forest policy formulation. We used the SWOT-AHP (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats analysis with the Analytical Hierarchy Process) framework to assess perceptions of three stakeholder groups (loggers, landowners, agency foresters) about forestry BMPs in Georgia, the largest roundwood producing state in the United States. The agency and logger stakeholder groups gave the highest priority to improved reputation under the strength category, whereas the landowner stakeholder group perceived sustainable forestry as the highest priority under the same category. Lack of landowner education was the highest priority under the weakness category for landowner and agency stakeholder groups, whereas the logger stakeholder group selected lack of trained personnel as the highest priority under the same category. Agency and landowner stakeholder groups gave the highest priority to training and education while loggers indicated maintenance of forest-based environmental benefits as their highest priority under the opportunity category. Finally, landowners and agency stakeholder groups perceived more regulations and restrictions as most significant in the threat category whereas the logger stakeholder group was most concerned about the insufficient accounting of cost sharing under the same category. Overall, selected stakeholder groups recognize the importance of forestry BMPs and had positive perceptions about them. A collaborative approach based on continuous feedback can streamline expectations of stakeholder groups about forestry BMPs in Georgia and several other states that are interested in maintaining high compliance rate of forestry BMPs for ensuring sustainable forest management.
林业最佳管理措施(BMPs)对于确保美国可持续森林管理至关重要,因为它们在保护水质、减少土壤侵蚀、维持河岸栖息地和维持场地生产力方面非常有效。林业 BMP 的成功在很大程度上取决于主要利益相关者群体之间的协调。了解这些群体的看法对于成功制定森林政策非常重要。我们使用 SWOT-AHP(优势、劣势、机会和威胁分析与层次分析法)框架来评估佐治亚州三个利益相关者群体(伐木工、土地所有者、机构林务员)对林业 BMP 的看法,佐治亚州是美国最大的原木生产州。机构和伐木工利益相关者群体在优势类别下将声誉提高列为最高优先级,而土地所有者利益相关者群体则认为可持续林业是同一类别下的最高优先级。缺乏土地所有者教育是土地所有者和机构利益相关者群体在劣势类别下的最高优先级,而伐木工利益相关者群体则选择缺乏培训人员作为同一类别下的最高优先级。机构和土地所有者利益相关者群体将培训和教育列为最高优先级,而伐木工则表示维护基于森林的环境效益是他们的最高优先级,属于机会类别。最后,土地所有者和机构利益相关者群体认为更多的法规和限制是最显著的威胁,而伐木工利益相关者群体则最关心同一类别下成本分担的不足。总体而言,选定的利益相关者群体认识到林业 BMP 的重要性,并对其持积极看法。基于持续反馈的协作方法可以简化利益相关者群体对佐治亚州和其他几个有兴趣保持林业 BMP 高合规率以确保可持续森林管理的州的林业 BMP 的期望。