Wong-Parodi Gabrielle, Dias M Beatrice, Taylor Michael
Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, United States.
Arviz, Inc, Pittsburgh, PA, United States.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2018 Mar 8;6(3):e48. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.8273.
Air quality affects us all and is a rapidly growing concern in the 21st century. We spend the majority of our lives indoors and can be exposed to a number of pollutants smaller than 2.5 microns (particulate matter, PM) resulting in detrimental health effects. Indoor air quality sensors have the potential to provide people with the information they need to understand their risk and take steps to reduce their exposure. One such sensor is the Speck sensor developed at the Community Robotics, Education and Technology Empowerment Lab at Carnegie Mellon University. This sensor provides users with continuous real-time and historical PM information, a Web-based platform where people can track their PM levels over time and learn about ways to reduce their exposure, and a venue (blog post) for the user community to exchange information. Little is known about how the use of such monitors affects people's knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors with respect to indoor air pollution.
The aim of this study was to assess whether using the sensor changes what people know and do about indoor air pollution.
We conducted 2 studies. In the first study, we recruited 276 Pittsburgh residents online and through local branches of the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, where the Speck sensor was made available by the researchers in the library catalog. Participants completed a 10- to 15-min survey on air pollution knowledge (its health impact, sources, and mitigation options), perceptions of indoor air quality, confidence in mitigation, current behaviors toward air quality, and personal empowerment and creativity in the spring and summer of 2016. In our second study, we surveyed 26 Pittsburgh residents in summer 2016 who checked out the Speck sensor for 3 weeks on the same measures assessed in the first study, with additional questions about the perception and use of the sensor. Follow-up interviews were conducted with a subset of those who used the Speck sensor.
A series of paired t tests found participants were significantly more knowledgeable (t=-2.61, P=.02), reported having significantly better indoor air quality (t=-5.20, P<.001), and felt more confident about knowing how to mitigate their risk (t=-1.87, P=.07) after using the Speck sensor than before. McNemar test showed participants tended to take more action to reduce indoor air pollution after using the sensor (χ=2.7, P=.10). Qualitative analysis suggested possible ripple effects of use, including encouraging family and friends to learn about indoor air pollution.
Providing people with low- or no-cost portable indoor air quality monitors, with a supporting Web-based platform that offers information about how to reduce risk, can help people better express perceptions and adopt behaviors commensurate with the risks they face. Thus, thoughtfully designed and deployed personal sensing devices can help empower people to take steps to reduce their risk.
空气质量影响着我们所有人,并且在21世纪正成为一个迅速受到更多关注的问题。我们一生中大部分时间都待在室内,可能会接触到许多小于2.5微米的污染物(颗粒物,PM),从而对健康产生有害影响。室内空气质量传感器有潜力为人们提供他们所需的信息,以便了解自身风险并采取措施减少接触。其中一种传感器是由卡内基梅隆大学社区机器人、教育与技术赋能实验室开发的Speck传感器。该传感器为用户提供连续的实时和历史PM信息、一个基于网络的平台,人们可以在该平台上长期追踪自己的PM水平并了解减少接触的方法,以及一个供用户社区交流信息的场所(博客文章)。关于使用此类监测器如何影响人们对室内空气污染的认知、态度和行为,我们所知甚少。
本研究的目的是评估使用该传感器是否会改变人们对室内空气污染的了解和行为。
我们进行了两项研究。在第一项研究中,我们通过线上以及匹兹堡卡内基图书馆的当地分馆招募了276名匹兹堡居民,研究人员在图书馆目录中提供了Speck传感器。参与者在2016年春季和夏季完成了一项10至15分钟的关于空气污染知识(其对健康的影响、来源和缓解措施)、对室内空气质量的认知、对缓解措施的信心、当前对空气质量的行为以及个人能力和创造力的调查。在第二项研究中,我们在2016年夏季对26名匹兹堡居民进行了调查,这些居民借用Speck传感器3周,调查内容与第一项研究中评估的相同,另外还增加了关于对传感器的认知和使用的问题。对使用Speck传感器的一部分人进行了后续访谈。
一系列配对t检验发现,与使用Speck传感器之前相比,参与者在使用后知识显著增加(t = -2.61,P = 0.02),报告的室内空气质量显著更好(t = -5.20,P < 0.001),并且对知道如何降低风险更有信心(t = -1.87,P = 0.07)。McNemar检验表明,参与者在使用传感器后倾向于采取更多行动来减少室内空气污染(χ = 2.7,P = 0.10)。定性分析表明使用可能产生的连锁反应,包括鼓励家人和朋友了解室内空气污染。
为人们提供低成本或免费的便携式室内空气质量监测器,并辅以一个基于网络的平台,提供有关如何降低风险的信息,可以帮助人们更好地表达认知并采取与他们所面临风险相称的行为。因此,经过精心设计和部署的个人传感设备可以帮助人们采取措施降低风险。