Department of Paediatrics, University Malaya Medical Centre, Kuala Lumpur 59100, Malaysia.
World J Gastroenterol. 2018 Mar 7;24(9):1013-1021. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v24.i9.1013.
To study implications of measuring quality indicators on training and trainees' performance in pediatric colonoscopy in a low-volume training center.
We reviewed retrospectively the performance of pediatric colonoscopies in a training center in Malaysia over 5 years (January 2010-December 2015), benchmarked against five quality indicators: appropriateness of indications, bowel preparations, cecum and ileal examination rates, and complications. The European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy guideline for pediatric endoscopy and North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition training guidelines were used as benchmarks.
Median (± SD) age of 121 children [males = 74 (61.2%)] who had 177 colonoscopies was 7.0 (± 4.6) years. On average, 30 colonoscopies were performed each year (range: 19-58). Except for investigations of abdominal pain (21/177, 17%), indications for colonoscopies were appropriate in the remaining 83%. Bowel preparation was good in 87%. One patient (0.6%) with severe Crohn's disease had bowel perforation. Cecum examination and ileal intubation rate was 95% and 68.1%. Ileal intubation rate was significantly higher in diagnosing or assessing inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) than non-IBD (72.9% 50.0% = 0.016). Performance of four trainees was consistent throughout the study period. Average cecum and ileal examination rate among trainees were 97% and 77%.
Benchmarking against established guidelines helps units with a low-volume of colonoscopies to identify area for further improvement.
研究在低容量培训中心,通过测量质量指标对儿科结肠镜检查培训和学员表现的影响。
我们回顾性地分析了马来西亚一个培训中心 5 年来(2010 年 1 月至 2015 年 12 月)的儿科结肠镜检查表现,该中心将五个质量指标与基准进行了比较:适应证的适宜性、肠道准备、盲肠和回肠检查率以及并发症。欧洲胃肠内镜学会儿科内镜指南和北美儿科学会胃肠病学、肝脏病学和营养学会培训指南被用作基准。
121 名儿童[男性=74(61.2%)]进行了 177 次结肠镜检查,中位数(±标准差)年龄为 7.0(±4.6)岁。平均每年进行 30 次结肠镜检查(范围:19-58)。除了腹痛(177 例中的 21 例,17%)的检查外,其余结肠镜检查适应证均适宜。肠道准备良好者占 87%。1 例(0.6%)患有严重克罗恩病的患者发生肠穿孔。盲肠检查和回肠插管率分别为 95%和 68.1%。回肠插管率在诊断或评估炎症性肠病(IBD)时明显高于非 IBD(72.9%比 50.0%=0.016)。4 名学员的表现贯穿整个研究期间。学员的平均盲肠和回肠检查率分别为 97%和 77%。
与既定指南进行基准比较有助于低容量结肠镜检查单位确定进一步改进的领域。