Liu T, Bao F L, Kang S J, Jiang T, Huang D S, Gao W, Geng L J, Hu Y M
Department of Orthopaedic Trauma, Qilu Hospital of Shandong University(Qingdao), Qingdao 266035, China.
Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2018 Mar 1;56(3):183-188. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.0529-5815.2018.03.004.
To explore a standard procedure for the treatment of combined dorsal and palmar internal fixation for complex four part distal radius fractures and assess its clinical results. From May 2009 to October 2016, 38 patients(39 sides)who suffered from complex four part distal radius fractures were performed operatively with open reduction and internal fixation via combined dorsal and palmar approach in Department of Orthopaedic Trauma, Qilu Hospital of Shandong University(Qingdao). The series included 22 males(22 sides) and 16 females(17 sides). Age of the patients was 53.5 years ranging from 25 to 79 years.According to Melone classification, there were 34 sides of type of Ⅳ, 5 of type Ⅴ.According to Frykman classification, there were 15 sides of type Ⅶ, 24 sides of type Ⅷ, and all the cases were type C3 according to AO/OTA classification.Preoperatively, the key articular fragments in four part distal radius fractures were identified and the individual fracture patterns from conventional X-ray and CT-scan were analyzed. All the patients were performed combined volar and dorsal fixation.Firstly, a palmar approach which gave access to and fix the palmar-ulnar fragment and the radial styloid fragment was performed.Then a limited dorsal approach across the third extensor compartment which gave access to the dorso-ulnar fragment and a limited dorsal arthrotomy to visualize the radiocarpal joint when necessary were performed.Through dorsal approach, we can address the dorso-ulnar fragment, free intra-articular fragment and direct visualize the joint.Use of a retinacular flap was routinely advocated to help prevent against tendon irritation and rupture.The follow-up control included conventional X-ray, range of motion(ROM), grip strength, and the disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand index(DASH), as well as the patient-rated wrist evaluation(PRWE) score for functional outcome at 6 and 12 months. Thirty-three patients(34 sides) were followed up for at least 12 months.The would healed well in all cases 2 weeks postoperatively, and no soft tissue infections, necrosis or neurovascular complications occurred.All the fractures of 38 cases(39 sides)healed averaged 3.6 months(ranging from 2.5-5.7 months), and no loss of reduction occurred postoperatively.Anatomic reconstruction with a step or gap of <1 mm was achieved in 37 cases(38 sides), Whereas 5 patients were lost to follow-up at 12 months postoperatively.ROM and grip strength were all recovered to over 85% of the unaffected side(exception of the bilateral patient). Median DASH-index and PRWE were 6.5(0-17) and 9.3(0-20)respectively. Combined volar and dorsal approaches allow achieving anatomic reconstruction in complex four part intra-articular distal radius fractures and reveal good functional outcomes at intermediate follow-up.
探讨复杂桡骨远端四部分骨折背侧和掌侧联合内固定治疗的标准手术方法,并评估其临床效果。2009年5月至2016年10月,山东大学齐鲁医院(青岛)创伤骨科对38例(39侧)复杂桡骨远端四部分骨折患者采用背侧和掌侧联合入路切开复位内固定术。该组包括22例男性(22侧)和16例女性(17侧)。患者年龄53.5岁,范围为25至79岁。根据Melone分类,Ⅳ型34侧,Ⅴ型5侧。根据Frykman分类,Ⅶ型15侧,Ⅷ型24侧,根据AO/OTA分类所有病例均为C3型。术前,确定桡骨远端四部分骨折的关键关节碎片,并分析常规X线和CT扫描的个体骨折模式。所有患者均采用掌侧和背侧联合固定。首先,采用掌侧入路,显露并固定掌侧尺侧碎片和桡骨茎突碎片。然后,经第三伸肌间隙行有限的背侧入路,显露背侧尺侧碎片,并在必要时行有限的背侧关节切开术以观察桡腕关节。通过背侧入路,可处理背侧尺侧碎片,游离关节内碎片并直接观察关节。常规采用支持带瓣以防止肌腱刺激和断裂。随访检查包括常规X线、活动范围(ROM)、握力、手臂、肩部和手部功能障碍指数(DASH),以及6个月和12个月时患者评定的腕关节功能评估(PRWE)评分。33例患者(34侧)至少随访12个月。所有病例术后2周伤口愈合良好,未发生软组织感染、坏死或神经血管并发症。38例(39侧)骨折均愈合,平均愈合时间3.6个月(范围2.5 - 5.7个月),术后无复位丢失。37例(38侧)实现了台阶或间隙<1mm的解剖重建,而5例患者术后12个月失访。ROM和握力均恢复至健侧的85%以上(双侧患者除外)。DASH指数中位数和PRWE分别为6.5(0 - 17)和9.3(0 - 20)。掌侧和背侧联合入路可实现复杂桡骨远端关节内四部分骨折的解剖重建,并在中期随访时显示出良好的功能结果。