Phillips Sara S, Tom Laura S, Bularzik Charito, Simon Melissa A
Obstetrics and Gynecology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, 60611, USA.
Rush Medical College, Chicago, IL, 60612, USA.
AIMS Public Health. 2014 Apr 6;1(2):51-59. doi: 10.3934/publichealth.2014.2.51. eCollection 2014.
Research on patient navigation has focused on validating the utility of navigators by defining their roles and analyzing their effects on patient outcomes, patient satisfaction, and cost effectiveness. Patient navigators are increasingly used outside the research context, and their roles without research responsibilities may look very different. This pilot study captured the activities of a community patient navigator for uninsured women with a positive screening test for breast cancer, using a time and motion approach over a period of three days. We followed the actions of this navigator minute by minute to assess the relative ratios of actions performed and to identify areas for time efficiency improvement to increase direct time with patients. This novel approach depicts the duties of a community patient navigator no longer fettered by navigation logs, research team meetings, surveys, and the consent process. We found that the community patient navigator was able to spend more time with patients in the clinical context relative to performing paperwork or logging communication with patients as a result of her lack of research responsibilities. By illuminating how community patient navigation functions as separate from the research setting, our results will inform future hiring and training of community patient navigators, system design and operations for improving the efficiency and efficacy of navigators, and our understanding of what community patient navigators do in the absence of research responsibilities.
患者导航研究主要集中在通过定义导航员的角色并分析他们对患者预后、患者满意度和成本效益的影响,来验证导航员的效用。在研究背景之外,患者导航员的使用越来越广泛,而且他们没有研究职责时的角色可能会大不相同。这项试点研究采用时间与动作分析方法,在三天时间里记录了一位社区患者导航员为乳腺癌筛查呈阳性的未参保女性提供服务的活动。我们逐分钟跟踪这位导航员的行动,以评估所执行行动的相对比例,并确定提高时间效率的领域,以便增加与患者直接接触的时间。这种新颖的方法描绘了社区患者导航员的职责,不再受导航日志、研究团队会议、调查和同意程序的束缚。我们发现,由于没有研究职责,这位社区患者导航员在临床环境中能够花更多时间陪伴患者,而不是处理文书工作或记录与患者的沟通情况。通过阐明社区患者导航与研究环境是如何分开运作的,我们的研究结果将为未来社区患者导航员的招聘和培训、提高导航员效率和效果的系统设计与运营,以及我们对社区患者导航员在没有研究职责时所做工作的理解提供参考。