Caltabiano Marie L, Croker Felicity, Page Lauren, Sklavos Anton, Spiteri Jade, Hanrahan Louise, Choi Richard
Psychology, College of Healthcare Sciences, James Cook University, McGregor Road, Smithfield, Cairns, Qld, 4878, Australia.
College of Medicine & Dentistry, James Cook University, Cairns, QLD, Australia.
BMC Oral Health. 2018 Mar 20;18(1):48. doi: 10.1186/s12903-018-0507-5.
This study investigated the expectations and experiences of a sample of new patients visiting an Australian regional university Student Dental Clinic with regard to anxiety provoking and alleviating stimuli in the clinical environment. Differences in anxiety levels were examined by age, gender and the type of procedure undergone.
The number of dental patients who participated in the study was 102 (56 males, 43 females). The study used a pre-treatment/post-treatment design to assess the effect of the dental procedure on anxiety levels of patients. The Modified Dental Anxiety Scale (MDAS) was used to measure anxiety levels in patients at pre-treatment. Questions were also asked about factors which may increase (length of the appointment, invasiveness of procedure) or decrease (perceived student interpersonal skills and clinical ability) dental fear.
Females reported higher total MDAS scores (M = 11.93) compared to males (M = 9.94). Younger patients (M = 12.15) had higher dental anxiety than older patients (M = 9.34). There was a reduction in dental anxiety from pre-treatment (M = 1.92) to post-treatment (M = 1.23) on the single item anxiety measure though most of the treatment being undergone by patients was for less complex procedures.
Patients' anticipatory experience of anxiety was higher than the anxiety experience after having undergone treatment at the student dental clinic. Student interpersonal skills and clinical ability as perceived by the patient can lessen dental anxiety in patients. Clinical Supervisor-student ratios need to be more equivalent in order to reduce the time length of appointments which currently are associated with increased patient anxiety levels in student dental clinics.
本研究调查了澳大利亚一所地区性大学学生牙科诊所的一组新患者对临床环境中引发焦虑和缓解焦虑刺激因素的期望和体验。通过年龄、性别和所接受治疗程序的类型来检查焦虑水平的差异。
参与该研究的牙科患者有102名(56名男性,43名女性)。该研究采用治疗前/治疗后设计来评估牙科治疗程序对患者焦虑水平的影响。改良牙科焦虑量表(MDAS)用于测量患者治疗前的焦虑水平。还询问了有关可能增加(预约时长、治疗程序的侵入性)或降低(感知到的学生人际交往能力和临床能力)牙科恐惧的因素的问题。
与男性(M = 9.94)相比,女性报告的MDAS总分更高(M = 11.93)。年轻患者(M = 12.15)比年长患者(M = 9.34)有更高的牙科焦虑。在单项焦虑测量中,从治疗前(M = 1.92)到治疗后(M = 1.23)牙科焦虑有所降低,不过患者所接受的大部分治疗都是针对不太复杂的程序。
患者对焦虑的预期体验高于在学生牙科诊所接受治疗后的焦虑体验。患者感知到的学生人际交往能力和临床能力可以减轻患者的牙科焦虑。临床督导与学生的比例需要更加均衡,以减少预约时长,目前预约时长与学生牙科诊所中患者焦虑水平的增加有关。