Department and Clinic of Internal Diseases, Diabetology and Nephrology, Metabolic Bone Diseases Unit, School of Medicine with the Division of Dentistry in Zabrze, Medical University of Silesia, Katowice, Poland.
Department and Chair of Pathomorphology, School of Medicine with the Division of Dentistry in Zabrze, Medical University of Silesia, Katowice, Poland.
Arch Osteoporos. 2018 Mar 26;13(1):35. doi: 10.1007/s11657-018-0446-4.
UNLABELLED: The study presents the research output of 40 globally top-ranked authors, publishing in the field of osteoporosis. Their h-index is compared with the Scientific Quality Index (SQI), a novel indicator. Using SQI, 92.5% of the authors changed their initial positions in the general ranking. SQI partially depends on bibliometric measures different from those influencing h-index and may be considered as an assessment tool, reflecting more objective, qualitative, rather than quantitative, features of individual scientific output. PURPOSE: The study approaches the research output of 40 globally top-ranked authors in the field of osteoporosis. METHODS: The assessed authors were identified in the Scopus database, using the key word "osteoporosis" and the h-index data, collected during the last decade (2008-2017). The data, concerning the scientific output, expressed by the h-index, were compared with a novel indicator of scientific quality-called the Scientific Quality Index (SQI). SQI is calculated according to the following formula: Parameter No. 1 + Parameter No. 2, where: Parameter No. 1 (the percent of papers cited ≥ 10 times) the number of papers cited ≥ 10 times (excluding self-citations and citations of all co-authors) is divided by the number of all the published papers (including the papers with no citation) × 100%, Parameter No. 2 (the mean number of citations per paper) the total number of citations (excluding self-citations and citations of all co-authors) divided by the number of all published papers (including papers with no citation). RESULTS: The following research output values were obtained: the citation index, 2483.6 ± 1348.7; the total number of papers, 75.1 ± 23.2; the total number of cited papers, 69.3 ± 22.0; the number of papers cited, at least, 10 times, 45.4 ± 17.2; the percent of papers cited, at least, 10 times, 59.9 ± 10.0; and the mean citations per paper, 32.8 ± 15.0. The mean value of Hirsch index was 24.2 ± 6.2 and SQI 92.7 ± 22.3. Using SQI, only three authors did not change their initial ranking position, established according to the h-index; 18 authors noted a decrease, while other 19 improved their initial ranking position. The h-index correlated with SQI; r = 0.72; p < 0.0001. CONCLUSION: Qualitative features of scientific output, reflected by SQI, have changed the classification of 92.5% of authors. SQI may be considered as an assessment tool which is more strongly determined by qualitative than quantitative features of individual scientific output.
未加标签:本研究呈现了 40 位全球排名靠前的骨质疏松症领域作者的研究成果。他们的 h 指数与科学质量指数(SQI)进行了比较,后者是一种新的指标。使用 SQI,92.5%的作者在总体排名中的初始位置发生了变化。SQI 在一定程度上取决于与影响 h 指数的指标不同的文献计量指标,因此可以被视为一种评估工具,反映了个体科研产出更客观、更定性而非定量的特征。
目的:本研究探讨了 40 位全球排名靠前的骨质疏松症领域作者的科研产出。
方法:在 Scopus 数据库中,使用“骨质疏松症”关键词和过去十年(2008-2017 年)收集的 h 指数数据,确定了评估作者。h 指数所代表的科研产出数据与一种新的科学质量指标-科学质量指数(SQI)进行了比较。SQI 是根据以下公式计算的:参数 1 + 参数 2,其中:参数 1(被引≥10 次的论文比例)被引≥10 次的论文数量(不包括自引和所有合著者的引用)除以所有发表论文数量(包括无引用的论文)×100%,参数 2(每篇论文的平均引用数)总引用次数(不包括自引和所有合著者的引用)除以所有发表论文数量(包括无引用的论文)。
结果:得到了以下研究成果值:引文指数 2483.6±1348.7;总论文数 75.1±23.2;被引论文总数 69.3±22.0;至少被引 10 次的论文数 45.4±17.2;至少被引 10 次的论文比例 59.9±10.0;每篇论文的平均引用数 32.8±15.0。赫希指数的平均值为 24.2±6.2,SQI 为 92.7±22.3。使用 SQI,只有 3 位作者的初始排名位置没有改变,这些排名是根据 h 指数确定的;18 位作者的排名下降,而其他 19 位作者的排名则有所提高。h 指数与 SQI 相关;r=0.72;p<0.0001。
结论:由 SQI 反映的科研产出的定性特征改变了 92.5%作者的分类。SQI 可以被视为一种评估工具,它更多地受到个体科研产出的定性特征而非定量特征的影响。
Arch Osteoporos. 2018-3-26
Orv Hetil. 2007-5-6
Acta Diabetol. 2016-2
Am J Orthop (Belle Mead NJ). 2018-3
J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2018-6
Orthop Rev (Pavia). 2021-1-28
J Health Serv Res Policy. 2014-4
Cell Cycle. 2012-9-14
Scientometrics. 2011-4
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2009-6-24
Retrovirology. 2008-11-25
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2005-11-15