Asan Ziya
Department of Neurosurgery, Faculty of Medicine, Ahi Evran University, Kirsehir, Turkey.
World Neurosurg. 2018 Jun;114:e1147-e1151. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2018.03.162. Epub 2018 Mar 31.
Patients with spinal cord injury without radiological abnormality (SCIWORA) show varying clinical prognostic courses independent of radiological findings. The fact that patients cannot be evaluated using a specific terminologic standard has led to the emergence of the real SCIWORA definition. In this study, clinical progressions of 11 patients diagnosed with SCIWORA were analyzed, and terminologic differences were discussed.
The clinical findings of 11 adults with a diagnosis of SCIWORA at the time of diagnosis and in the long term were analyzed according to the ASIA classification scheme. The presence of a correlation between radiological findings from the early and late periods and the clinical findings was investigated. High-dose methylprednisolone treatment was administered to all newly diagnosed patients in the early period, and the clinical response was observed. Clinical, prognostic, and radiological comparisons with SCIWORA cases reported in the literature were conducted.
Seven patients received a diagnosis of cervical SCIWORA, and 4 patients had thoracal SCIWORA. Neurologic findings at the time of diagnosis and in the early and late periods vary independent of radiological findings. In the cases where significant neurologic recovery was not observed within the first 3 days, significant recovery also was not seen in the later period. In the cases where neurologic recovery was seen, improvements in sphincter function and sensory and motor deficits were observed.
In patients diagnosed with SCIWORA, early neurologic response is the determining factor for prognosis. Clinical findings and prognosis demonstrate no correlation with radiological findings.
无放射学异常的脊髓损伤(SCIWORA)患者表现出与放射学检查结果无关的不同临床预后过程。由于无法使用特定的术语标准对患者进行评估,真正的SCIWORA定义应运而生。本研究分析了11例诊断为SCIWORA患者的临床进展情况,并讨论了术语差异。
根据美国脊髓损伤协会(ASIA)分类方案,分析了11例确诊为SCIWORA的成人患者在诊断时及长期的临床检查结果。研究了早期和晚期放射学检查结果与临床检查结果之间的相关性。所有新诊断患者在早期均接受大剂量甲泼尼龙治疗,并观察临床反应。与文献报道的SCIWORA病例进行了临床、预后和放射学比较。
7例患者诊断为颈髓SCIWORA,4例为胸髓SCIWORA。诊断时及早期和晚期的神经学检查结果各不相同,与放射学检查结果无关。在最初3天内未观察到明显神经功能恢复的病例中,后期也未出现明显恢复。在出现神经功能恢复的病例中,观察到括约肌功能以及感觉和运动功能障碍有所改善。
在诊断为SCIWORA的患者中,早期神经学反应是预后的决定因素。临床检查结果和预后与放射学检查结果无关。