Zens Tiffany J, Rogers Andrew P, Riedesel Erica L, Leys Charles M, Ostlie Daniel J, Woods Michael A, Gill Kara G
Division of Pediatric Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, WI; American Family Children's Hospital, University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics, Madison, WI.
Division of Pediatric Radiology, Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, WI; American Family Children's Hospital, University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics, Madison, WI.
J Pediatr Surg. 2018 Jun;53(6):1168-1174. doi: 10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2018.02.078. Epub 2018 Mar 6.
Contrast-enhanced CT remains the first-line imaging for evaluating postoperative abscess (POA) after appendicitis. Given concerns of ionizing radiation use in children, we began utilizing quick MRI to evaluate POA and summarize our findings in this study.
Children imaged with quick MRI from 2015 to 2017 were compared to children evaluated with CT from 2012 to 2014 using an age and weight matched case-control model. Radiation exposure, size and number of abscesses, length of exam, drain placement, and patient outcomes were compared.
There was no difference in age or weight (p>0.60) between children evaluated with quick MRI (n=16) and CT (n=16). Mean imaging time was longer (18.2±8.5min) for MRI (p<0.001), but there was no difference in time from imaging order to drain placement (p=0.969). No children required sedation or had non-diagnostic imaging. There were no differences in abscess volume (p=0.346) or drain placement (p=0.332). Thirty-day follow-up showed no difference in readmissions (p=0.551) and no missed abscesses. Quick MRI reduced imaging charges to $1871 from $5650 with CT.
Quick MRI demonstrated equivalent outcomes to CT in terms of POA detection, drain placement, and 30-day complications suggesting that MRI provides an equally effective, less expensive, and non-radiation modality for the identification of POA.
Retrospective Case-Control Study.
Level III.
增强CT仍然是评估阑尾炎术后脓肿(POA)的一线成像方法。鉴于对儿童使用电离辐射的担忧,我们开始利用快速MRI来评估POA,并在本研究中总结我们的发现。
采用年龄和体重匹配的病例对照模型,将2015年至2017年接受快速MRI成像的儿童与2012年至2014年接受CT评估的儿童进行比较。比较辐射暴露、脓肿的大小和数量、检查时间、引流管放置情况及患者预后。
接受快速MRI(n = 16)和CT(n = 16)评估的儿童在年龄或体重方面无差异(p>0.60)。MRI的平均成像时间较长(18.2±8.5分钟)(p<0.001),但从成像到放置引流管的时间无差异(p = 0.969)。没有儿童需要镇静或成像结果不明确。脓肿体积(p = 0.346)或引流管放置情况(p = 0.332)无差异。30天随访显示再入院率无差异(p = 0.551),且无脓肿漏诊。快速MRI使成像费用从CT的5650美元降至1871美元。
在POA检测、引流管放置和30天并发症方面,快速MRI显示出与CT相当的结果,这表明MRI为POA的识别提供了一种同样有效、成本更低且无辐射的方式。
回顾性病例对照研究。
三级。