Lee Dong-Hee, Yoo Soonil, Shin Eunhye, Cho Yesun
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, College of Medicine, The Catholic University of Korea, Seoul, Korea.
J Audiol Otol. 2018 Jul;22(3):160-166. doi: 10.7874/jao.2018.00101. Epub 2018 Jun 14.
This study aimed 1) to compare the rates of surgical site infection (SSI) between two groups with and without preoperative hair shaving, 2) to compare the bacterial colonization just before the skin incision between them, and 3) to evaluate people's preference for the hair shaving.
The retrospective study enrolled cases in which middle ear and mastoid surgery was performed with as well as without hair removal. Main measurement outcomes were the SSI rate within 3 months following the surgery, bacterial culture results obtained from the incision area just before the skin incision, and questionnaire to evaluate the preference for hair shaving from patients with chronic suppurative otitis media but without experience with the ear surgery.
This study did not show any difference in the rates of SSI and bacterial colonization between two groups with and without preoperative hair shaving. Most patients without experience with the ear surgery chose the nonshaved ear surgery, even though the questionnaire presented a comment as follow; "Your hair will always grow back as the growth speed of about 1.25 cm per month."
There is no evidence showing that preoperative shaving of the surgical site is helpful for the SSI than no hair removal. Nonshaved middle ear and mastoid surgery via postauricular approach appears to be preferable. Contrary to doctors' popular belief, the hair shaving can cause psychological discomfort, especially for women. Now is the time to keep the balance between the professional's perspective and the patients' preferences.
本研究旨在1)比较术前剃毛组与未剃毛组的手术部位感染(SSI)发生率;2)比较两组在皮肤切开前的细菌定植情况;3)评估患者对剃毛的偏好。
这项回顾性研究纳入了接受中耳和乳突手术且有或没有进行毛发去除的病例。主要测量指标为术后3个月内的SSI发生率、皮肤切开前从切口区域获得的细菌培养结果,以及对慢性化脓性中耳炎但无耳部手术经验患者进行的关于剃毛偏好的问卷调查。
本研究未显示术前剃毛组与未剃毛组在SSI发生率和细菌定植方面存在任何差异。大多数无耳部手术经验的患者选择了不剃毛的耳部手术,尽管调查问卷中有如下表述:“你的头发总会再长出来,生长速度约为每月1.25厘米。”
没有证据表明术前对手术部位进行剃毛比不剃毛对预防SSI更有帮助。经耳后入路的不剃毛中耳和乳突手术似乎更可取。与医生的普遍看法相反,剃毛会引起心理不适,尤其是对女性而言。现在是时候在专业观点和患者偏好之间保持平衡了。