Doukaki Christina, MedVet Dr, Beaufrère Hugues, Vet Dr Med, Huynh Minh
J Avian Med Surg. 2018 Jun;32(2):109-114. doi: 10.1647/2017-294.
International conferences on avian medicine and surgery aim to disseminate scientific and evidence-based information in the form of oral presentations and posters. Most manuscripts presented are printed in the conference proceedings as abstracts. Subsequent publication in a scientific peer-reviewed journal is the natural outcome of the research cycle, although studies have shown that the vast majority of conference abstracts are not published. The purpose of this study was to explore 1) the fate of abstracts presented in avian conferences (Association of Avian Veterinarians, European Association of Avian Veterinarians, International Conference on Avian Herpetological and Exotic Mammal Medicine) in the years 2011-2015, 2) assess the publication rate in peer-reviewed journals, 3) describe the time course of subsequent publication, and 4) identify factors associated with increased likelihood of publication. The results showed that 24% of conference abstracts were published within the next 2 years. Depending on the statistical model used, several factors were identified as associated with increased publication rate. North American papers seem to publish with more frequency (univariate model), while European papers had the opposite trend (multivariable model). Likewise, experimental studies were more prone to being published overall (univariate model), whereas retrospective observational studies had a lower rate of publication (multivariable model). Increasing the number of authors was also associated with increased publication rate. Most publications were published in the Journal of Avian Medicine and Surgery, which tends to suggest that this journal is the main journal of the specialty. Some parameters highlighted in this study may assist conference attendees to assess the likelihood of later publication.
鸟类医学与外科学国际会议旨在以口头报告和海报的形式传播科学且基于证据的信息。大多数提交的稿件会以摘要形式发表在会议论文集中。后续在科学同行评审期刊上发表是研究周期的自然结果,不过研究表明绝大多数会议摘要并未发表。本研究的目的是探讨:1)2011年至2015年间在鸟类会议(鸟类兽医协会、欧洲鸟类兽医协会、鸟类爬行动物与外来哺乳动物医学国际会议)上发表的摘要的去向;2)评估在同行评审期刊上的发表率;3)描述后续发表的时间进程;4)确定与发表可能性增加相关的因素。结果显示,24%的会议摘要在接下来的两年内发表。根据所使用的统计模型,确定了几个与发表率增加相关的因素。北美论文似乎发表频率更高(单变量模型),而欧洲论文则呈现相反趋势(多变量模型)。同样,总体而言实验性研究更易于发表(单变量模型),而回顾性观察性研究的发表率较低(多变量模型)。作者数量增加也与发表率提高相关。大多数发表的论文发表在《鸟类医学与外科学杂志》上,这往往表明该杂志是该专业的主要期刊。本研究中突出的一些参数可能有助于会议参与者评估后续发表的可能性。