Del Do Michael, Song Sungjin A, Nesbitt Nicholas B, Spaw Mark C, Chang Edward T, Liming Bryan J, Cable Benjamin B, Camacho Macario
Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, 1 Jarrett White Road, Tripler Army Medical Center, HI, 96859, USA.
Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, 1 Jarrett White Road, Tripler Army Medical Center, HI, 96859, USA.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2018 Aug;111:69-74. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2018.05.022. Epub 2018 May 24.
The objective of this study is to review the published literature on supraglottoplasty techniques for correcting laryngomalacia, and to subsequently provide a standardized classification system.
Three authors independently and systematically searched Pubmed/MEDLINE and six additional databases for all studies that included descriptions of supraglottoplasty techniques for correcting laryngomalacia. Sub-sites operated on and specific technique descriptions were reviewed, cataloged and subsequently categorized. This data was then used to develop a new classification system.
231 articles were identified, downloaded and reviewed in full text. 53 articles with 1669 patients from the included articles described in detail the supraglottoplasty procedure. 84 articles with 5731 patients had to be excluded secondary to not providing detail about the supraglottoplasty procedure. The resultant data identifies the need for a more standardized reporting of the supraglottoplasty procedure in order to more accurately evaluate technique specific outcomes. Currently 77% of the patients in the literature cannot be assessed for outcomes as they did not describe the details for the procedures. Eight variations of supraglottoplasty and four variations of epiglottis surgery were described. Based on the literature, we consolidated the surgery into the following types: Type 1: Debulking of arytenoids, Type 2: Division of aryepiglottic folds, Type 3: Epiglottis surgery.
This descriptive review identified 53 articles with 1669 patients from the included articles detailing multiple variations of supraglottoplasty techniques. The new classification supplements a previously established system describing laryngomalacia, and simplifies the supraglottoplasty into three descriptive and logical types of categories. Our classification system would give surgeons a universal language to describe the supraglottoplasty performed, which could improve reporting of techniques, and facilitate future communication and research.
本研究的目的是回顾已发表的关于声门上成形术治疗喉软化症的文献,并随后提供一个标准化的分类系统。
三位作者独立且系统地在PubMed/MEDLINE及另外六个数据库中检索所有包含声门上成形术治疗喉软化症描述的研究。对手术的亚部位及具体技术描述进行回顾、编目并随后分类。然后使用这些数据开发一个新的分类系统。
共识别出231篇文章,下载并全文审阅。其中53篇文章(涉及1669例患者)详细描述了声门上成形术。另外84篇文章(涉及5731例患者)因未详细描述声门上成形术而被排除。所得数据表明需要更标准化地报告声门上成形术,以便更准确地评估特定技术的结果。目前文献中77%的患者无法评估其结果,因为他们未描述手术细节。文中描述了声门上成形术的八种变体及会厌手术的四种变体。基于文献,我们将手术归纳为以下类型:1型:杓状软骨减容术;2型:杓会厌襞切开术;3型:会厌手术。
这项描述性综述从纳入的文章中识别出53篇文章(涉及1669例患者),详细介绍了声门上成形术技术的多种变体。新的分类补充了先前建立的描述喉软化症的系统,并将声门上成形术简化为三种描述性且符合逻辑的类别类型。我们的分类系统将为外科医生提供一种通用语言来描述所施行的声门上成形术,这可以改善技术报告,并促进未来的交流与研究。