Department of Disability and Human Development, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.
Disabil Rehabil. 2019 Dec;41(25):3079-3089. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2018.1483436. Epub 2018 Jul 2.
This paper addresses how Medicaid personal care attendant (PCA) service users with physical disabilities experience barriers to cross-state movement arising from the interstate variation in these programs. Using the Moves in Context model, this analysis focuses on the structural-level influences on individual cross-state move trajectories. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 18 Medicaid PCA service users who were considering or pursuing cross-state moves motivated by opportunity. Questions addressed the cross-state move process; social participation; education and employment; and access to PCA services. Grounded theory methods were used to analyze interview transcripts and generate analytic codes and categories. Participants described their experiences with interstate variation in Medicaid PCA services in terms of (1) contending with conflicts between the need for services and the desire for cross-state moves; (2) navigating "hoops of fire"; and (3) recasting imagined futures. Participants also expressed experiences of intrastate confinement, or being stuck in their current state (4) using metaphors of immobility and (5) recognizing intrastate confinement as a form of categorical exclusion. Interstate variation in Medicaid PCA policy impedes program users' ability to pursue educational and occupational advancement, and leads to feelings of second-class citizenship. Policy changes should be explored to affirm the autonomy of Medicaid PCA service users.Implications for Rehabilitation Interstate variation in Medicaid PCA services and cross-state moves • Medicaid personal care assistance service users desire and pursue cross-state moves, especially when drawn by educational or employment opportunities. • Interstate variation in Medicaid policy negatively impacts the ability for PCA service program users to pursue these moves due to gaps or delays in service access, creating inequity in opportunity and feelings of second-class citizenship. • Individual users of Medicaid PCA services need information and services as they plan pursue cross-state moves. • States and the Center of Medicare and Medicaid Services should offer guidance to support the independent living, educational, and economic goals of users of PCA services who desire cross-state moves.
本文探讨了 Medicaid 个人护理助理 (PCA) 服务使用者在身体残疾方面如何面临这些计划在州际间的差异所导致的跨境移动障碍。本文使用“情境中的移动”模型,重点关注对个人跨境移动轨迹的结构性影响。对 18 名正在考虑或出于机会考虑进行跨境移动的 Medicaid PCA 服务使用者进行了半结构化访谈。问题涉及跨境移动过程、社会参与、教育和就业以及获得 PCA 服务。使用扎根理论方法对访谈记录进行分析,生成分析代码和类别。参与者根据以下几个方面描述了他们在 Medicaid PCA 服务方面的州际差异体验:(1) 应对服务需求与跨境移动愿望之间的冲突;(2) 穿越“火圈”;(3) 重塑想象中的未来。参与者还表达了他们在州内受到限制的体验,或者被困在当前状态中(4) 使用无法移动的隐喻;(5) 将州内限制视为一种类别排斥。Medicaid PCA 政策的州际差异阻碍了计划使用者追求教育和职业发展的能力,并导致二等公民的感觉。应探讨政策变化,以确认 Medicaid PCA 服务使用者的自主权。
康复的意义
Medicaid PCA 服务的州际差异和跨境移动
• Medicaid 个人护理援助服务使用者渴望并追求跨境移动,特别是在受到教育或就业机会吸引时。
• Medicaid 政策在州际间的差异对 PCA 服务计划使用者追求这些移动的能力产生负面影响,因为服务准入存在差距或延迟,从而造成机会不平等和二等公民的感觉。
• Medicaid PCA 服务的个人使用者在计划跨境移动时需要信息和服务。
• 各州和医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心应提供指导,以支持渴望跨境移动的 PCA 服务使用者的独立生活、教育和经济目标。