Beveridge A
Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh, 9 Queen Street, Edinburgh EH2 1JQ, UK,
J R Coll Physicians Edinb. 2018 Sep;48(3):272-283. doi: 10.4997/JRCPE.2018.315.
Sir Alexander Morison's The Physiognomy of Mental Diseases and the original art work that formed the basis of the book have not had the scholarly attention they deserve. The published book and the commissioned portraits have not been studied in any detail. Historians have tended to offer cursory assessments that have reflected their own preconceived ideas rather than properly engaging with the material. This is a pity because Morison's work is a rich source that tells us much about the history of psychiatry. The pictures and text give us a glimpse into the world of the asylum and that of the patient. Although we see the patient through the eyes of the artist and Dr Morison, they do emerge as individuals. The accompanying texts reflect the psychiatric approach of the time and reveal contemporary notions of diagnosis, aetiology and treatment. Morison's work can also be located in the history of ideas about physiognomy. He himself was particularly influenced by Jean-Étienne-Dominique Esquirol, and Morison's work, in turn, influenced WAF Browne. These papers will outline Morison's career and consider in detail his book on The Physiognomy of Mental Diseases.
亚历山大·莫里森爵士的《精神疾病的面相学》以及作为该书基础的原始艺术作品,并未得到它们应有的学术关注。已出版的书籍和委托绘制的肖像画都没有得到过详细研究。历史学家们往往只是进行了粗略的评估,这些评估反映的是他们自己先入为主的观念,而不是对这些材料进行恰当的研究。这很可惜,因为莫里森的作品是一个丰富的资源,能让我们了解到很多精神病学的历史。这些图片和文字让我们得以一窥精神病院和患者的世界。尽管我们是通过艺术家和莫里森医生的视角来看待患者,但他们确实展现出了个体的特点。附带文字反映了当时的精神病学方法,揭示了当代的诊断、病因学和治疗观念。莫里森的作品也可以置于面相学思想的历史背景中。他本人尤其受到让 - 艾蒂安 - 多米尼克·埃斯基罗尔的影响,而莫里森的作品反过来又影响了WAF布朗。这些论文将概述莫里森的职业生涯,并详细探讨他关于《精神疾病的面相学》的著作。