Dereli Ayse Kurtulus, Zeybek Volkan, Sagtas Ergin, Senol Hande, Ozgul Hakan Abdullah, Acar Kemalettin
Faculty of Medicine, Department of Forensic Medicine, Pamukkale University, Denizli, Turkey.
Faculty of Medicine, Department of Radiology, Pamukkale University, Denizli, Turkey.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2018 Dec;14(4):450-459. doi: 10.1007/s12024-018-0029-0. Epub 2018 Sep 19.
Sex determination is a major area of investigation in forensic anthropology. As technology has advanced, imaging methods such as computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging are being investigated as alternatives to conventional forensic anthropological research techniques. This study aimed to investigate the suitability of three-dimensional (3D) modeling of volumetric cranial computed tomography (CCT) images for sex estimation from skull morphology. In this study, CCT angiography images from the Department of Radiology 2017 archives were used retrospectively, and 3D images were obtained after the reconstruction of 85 cases of CCT images. The sex-dependent morphological characteristics of the skull were evaluated by three blinded observers and scored on a scale of 1-5 points according to the "Standards for Data Collection from Human Skeletal Remains". The accurate sex estimation rates of the first, second and third observers were 91.8, 92.9 and 92.9%, respectively. The rate of accurate sex estimation for males was 98-100%, while this rate varied between 83.3-86.1% for females. Consistency in sex estimation between the three observers was 83.5%, with a Kappa value of 0.763 (z = 12.2; p = 0.0001*). The glabella was the most effective morphological trait used to estimate sex. The results of this study show that sex can be estimated from morphological features in volume-rendered CCT 3D images. Thus, sex can be estimated by digital images without the need for maceration processes, and the transfer of digital data in place of physical material will make it possible to gain expert opinions in forensic anthropology.
性别鉴定是法医人类学的一个主要研究领域。随着技术的进步,诸如计算机断层扫描和磁共振成像等成像方法正在作为传统法医人类学研究技术的替代方法进行研究。本研究旨在探讨容积性颅骨计算机断层扫描(CCT)图像的三维(3D)建模在根据颅骨形态进行性别估计方面的适用性。在本研究中,回顾性使用了放射科2017年档案中的CCT血管造影图像,对85例CCT图像进行重建后获得了3D图像。由三名不知情的观察者评估颅骨的性别相关形态特征,并根据《人类骨骼遗骸数据收集标准》按1 - 5分进行评分。第一、第二和第三观察者的准确性别估计率分别为91.8%、92.9%和92.9%。男性的准确性别估计率为98 - 100%,而女性的这一比率在83.3 - 86.1%之间变化。三名观察者之间性别估计的一致性为83.5%,Kappa值为0.763(z = 12.2;p = 0.0001*)。眉间是用于估计性别的最有效形态特征。本研究结果表明,可以从容积渲染的CCT 3D图像中的形态特征估计性别。因此,无需浸软处理就可以通过数字图像估计性别,并且用数字数据代替实物材料进行传输将使得有可能在法医人类学中获得专家意见。