Department of Medical Affairs, Peking Union Medical College Hospital Peking, China.
Department of Infectious Diseases, Peking Union Medical College Hospital, Peking, China.
Clin Microbiol Infect. 2019 Jun;25(6):759.e9-759.e14. doi: 10.1016/j.cmi.2018.09.005. Epub 2018 Sep 27.
We aimed to assess the status and possible problems of antimicrobial stewardship (AMS) in Grade-A tertiary hospitals in China.
A questionnaire was designed according to the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 'Core Elements of Hospital Antibiotic Stewardship Programs'. We extracted 10-15% from Grade A tertiary hospitals in every province of mainland China; 165 hospitals in total were selected. Electronic questionnaires were forwarded to these hospitals.
Of the hospitals surveyed, 116 (70.3%) responded. Participating hospitals accounted for 8.9% (116/1308) of all the Grade A tertiary hospitals in mainland China, covering all provinces and municipalities. Our study revealed that an AMS team was set up for an antimicrobial stewardship programme (ASP) in 110 hospitals (94.8%). Thirty hospitals lacked a formal department of infectious diseases (DID). A formal DID can positively promote an ASP. More hospitals with a formal DID developed their internal guidelines (54.7% versus 33.3%, p 0.044) and technical documents (83.7% versus 63.3%, p 0.019) on antimicrobial use than hospitals without a formal DID. All the 116 hospitals strengthened appropriate use of antimicrobials by some administration-dominated measures, among which the most frequent measures were classification management of antimicrobial agents (114 hospitals, 98.3%) and post-prescription review with feedback (106 hospitals, 91.4%). Prescription preauthorization and pre-prescription review with feedback were implemented in nearly 50% of the hospitals. More hospitals with a DID conducted pre-prescription review with feedback (53.5% versus 26.7%, p 0.027). The most frequent indicator to assess the impact of AMS was the defined daily dose (DDD) (103 hospitals, 96.3%).
The survey showed significant achievements in China in AMS, mainly including the antibiotic consumption index; there is still a lot of work to be done, such as how to evaluate patient safety and infection outcome after strict restriction of antibiotic use.
评估中国甲级三级医院抗菌药物管理(AMS)的现状和可能存在的问题。
根据美国疾病控制与预防中心“医院抗生素管理计划核心要素”设计问卷,从中国大陆各省份的甲级三级医院中抽取 10-15%,共选择 165 家医院。将电子问卷转发给这些医院。
在接受调查的医院中,有 116 家(70.3%)做出了回应。参与医院占中国大陆甲级三级医院总数的 8.9%(116/1308),覆盖了所有省份和直辖市。研究表明,110 家医院(94.8%)为抗菌药物管理计划(ASP)设立了 AMS 团队。30 家医院缺乏正式的感染科(DID)。正式的 DID 可以积极促进 ASP 的发展。更多设有正式 DID 的医院制定了内部抗菌药物使用指南(54.7%对 33.3%,p<0.044)和技术文件(83.7%对 63.3%,p<0.019)。所有 116 家医院都通过一些以行政管理为主的措施加强了抗菌药物的合理使用,其中最常见的措施是抗菌药物分类管理(114 家医院,98.3%)和处方后审核与反馈(106 家医院,91.4%)。处方授权前审核和处方前审核与反馈在近 50%的医院中得到实施。更多设有 DID 的医院进行了处方前审核与反馈(53.5%对 26.7%,p<0.027)。评估 AMS 影响的最常见指标是限定日剂量(DDD)(103 家医院,96.3%)。
调查显示,中国在 AMS 方面取得了显著成就,主要包括抗生素消耗指标;在严格限制抗生素使用后如何评估患者安全和感染结局方面,仍有大量工作要做。