Al-Asmar Ayah Abdullah, Al-Khatib Khaled M, Al-Amad Tareq Z, Sawair Faleh A
1 Department of Conservative Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan.
2 Private practice, Amman, Jordan.
J Int Med Res. 2019 Jan;47(1):361-369. doi: 10.1177/0300060518802523. Epub 2018 Oct 3.
To assess Jordanian dentists' current perception and attitudes towards amalgam and composite restorations four years after the Minamata treaty was endorsed and suggest decision making factors that may influence the type of restoration requested by patients.
The cross-sectional study was conducted through structured questionnaires distributed to dentists in Amman, Jordan from June 2017 to February 2018.
Of the 1686 dentists who were contacted 758 dentists (response rate 45%) responded to the questionnaire either by email or via field visits. Jordanian dentists used more composite restorations than amalgam. Recurrent caries followed by fracture of the restoration were the main reasons for replacement of both fillings by dentists. However, dentists suggested that the main reason patients requested replacement of amalgam was for 'staining'. In addition, a large proportion of the dentists had experienced patients who had asked either for replacement of amalgam (77%) or refused an amalgam filling (99%) for aesthetic reasons. In the opinion of the dentists, only 20% patients requested replacement of amalgam because of the mercury content.
The findings of this survey suggest that a 'phase-down' of dental amalgam is being implemented in Jordan's dental clinics but it is not associated with commitment to the Minamata Convention, rather to current dental practice trends and patients' aesthetic demands.
评估在《水俣公约》获得批准四年后约旦牙医对汞合金和复合树脂修复体的当前认知及态度,并提出可能影响患者所要求修复体类型的决策因素。
通过在2017年6月至2018年2月期间向约旦安曼的牙医发放结构化问卷进行横断面研究。
在联系的1686名牙医中,758名牙医(回复率45%)通过电子邮件或实地走访回复了问卷。约旦牙医使用复合树脂修复体多于汞合金修复体。继发龋随后是修复体折断是牙医更换这两种充填物的主要原因。然而,牙医表示患者要求更换汞合金的主要原因是“染色”。此外,很大一部分牙医遇到过患者因美观原因要求更换汞合金(77%)或拒绝汞合金充填(99%)的情况。在牙医看来,只有20%的患者因汞含量要求更换汞合金。
本次调查结果表明,约旦的牙科诊所正在实施逐步减少牙科汞合金的使用,但这并非与对《水俣公约》的承诺相关,而是与当前的牙科实践趋势和患者的美观需求有关。