Křivohlávek M, Šrám J, Pazour J, Kloub M
Traumacentrum, Krajská nemocnice Liberec.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2018;85(2):113-119.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY The locked nailing of diaphyseal fractures of the tibia currently represents a method of choice for treating the closed diaphyseal fractures, some of the tibial metaphyseal fractures and open tibial diaphyseal fractures classified as grade I and II according to Gustilo-Anderson (GA) classification. The suprapatellar (SP) approach is an alternative technique of insertion of the nail in semi-extension of the lower extremity with easier reduction, namely of multiple fractures and proximal diaphyseal fractures of the tibia in particular. This study aims to evaluate the group of patients in whom the suprapatellar approach was used and who were followed up for the period of at least 12 months. MATERIAL AND METHODS The prospective study included 55 cases of osteosynthesis of diaphyseal fractures of the tibia with the surgery performed in the period from January 2013 to June 2015, of which in 53 patients (17 women and 36 men) with the mean age of 49.6± 16.7 years the ETN nail by DePuy Synthes ® was inserted through a suprapatellar approach. In 38 cases (70.1%) an isolated trauma was involved, 15 patients (29.9%) were treated for multiple injuries or polytrauma. In nine cases (17%) it was an open fracture (2times - GA grade I, 7times - GA grade II). A multiple fracture or a fracture of the proximal third was recorded in 19 cases (34.5%). The functional and radiological results of the treatment were assessed prospectively at 12 months after the surgery using the Lysholm (LS) score. RESULTS The final functional results were successfully assessed in 49 performed osteosyntheses (89.1%). The mean duration of surgery was 72.7± 19.57 min (40-140 min, median 65 min). A total of 48 (98%) fractures healed by primary intention. In five cases (10.2%) a delayed healing occurred and in one case (2 %) non-union was reported, requiring a revision surgery. In three cases (6.1%) complete implant was removed (twice by SP and once by IP approach). The mean Lysholm score was 93.4 ± 8.39 points (59-100 points, median score of 95 points). An excellent or a good result was observed in 45 patients (91.8%), a satisfactory result in three patients (6.2%), and a poor result in one patient (2%). A statistically significant correlation (p = 0.006) between the LS score values and the age of the patients was confirmed. In patients up to 60 years of age the LS score was 96.2 ± 4.51 points (89-100, median 96), at the age of more than 60 years it was 86.9 ± 11.46 (59-100, median 89). CONCLUSIONS The suprapatellar approach in treating the tibial diaphyseal fractures represents a safe alternative nail insertion technique. If an appropriate surgical technique is applied, the risks inherent in this approach are negligible. The approach allows for an easy reduction of challenging fractures of the proximal third diaphyseal fracture of the tibia and multiple fractures of the tibia and facilitates an easy check of the axial position of the extremity. The functional results of the knee joint are comparable to those achieved with the infrapatellar nailing technique. The final LS score correlates with the age of the patients. Key words:tibial fractures, suprapatellar approach, intramedullary nailing, knee pain.
研究目的 目前,胫骨干骨折的带锁髓内钉固定术是治疗闭合性胫骨干骨折、部分胫骨近端骨折以及根据 Gustilo-Anderson(GA)分类为 I 级和 II 级的开放性胫骨干骨折的一种首选方法。髌上(SP)入路是在下肢半伸直位插入髓内钉的一种替代技术,复位更容易,尤其是对于多发骨折和胫骨近端干骺端骨折。本研究旨在评估采用髌上入路且随访至少 12 个月的患者群体。
材料与方法 这项前瞻性研究纳入了 2013 年 1 月至 2015 年 6 月期间进行手术的 55 例胫骨干骨折骨固定病例,其中 53 例患者(17 名女性和 36 名男性),平均年龄 49.6±16.7 岁,通过髌上入路插入 DePuy Synthes®的 ETN 髓内钉。38 例(70.1%)为单纯创伤,15 例(29.9%)为多发伤或复合伤。9 例(17%)为开放性骨折(2 例为 GA I 级,7 例为 GA II 级)。19 例(34.5%)记录为多发骨折或近端三分之一骨折。术后 12 个月采用 Lysholm(LS)评分对治疗的功能和影像学结果进行前瞻性评估。
结果 49 例(89.1%)已完成的骨固定术成功评估了最终功能结果。手术平均时长为 72.7±19.57 分钟(40 - 140 分钟,中位数 65 分钟)。共 48 例(98%)骨折一期愈合。5 例(10.2%)出现延迟愈合,1 例(2%)报告为骨不连,需要进行翻修手术。3 例(6.1%)取出了完整植入物(2 次通过 SP 入路,1 次通过髌下入路)。平均 Lysholm 评分为 93.4±8.39 分(59 - 100 分,中位数 95 分)。45 例患者(91.8%)结果为优或良,3 例患者(6.2%)结果为满意,1 例患者(2%)结果为差。证实 LS 评分值与患者年龄之间存在统计学显著相关性(p = 0.006)。60 岁及以下患者的 LS 评分为 96.2±4.51 分(89 - 100,中位数 96),60 岁以上患者为 86.9±11.46 分(59 - 100,中位数 89)。
结论 髌上入路治疗胫骨干骨折是一种安全的髓内钉插入替代技术。如果应用适当的手术技术,该入路固有的风险可忽略不计。该入路便于复位胫骨近端三分之一干骺端具有挑战性的骨折以及胫骨多发骨折,并有助于轻松检查下肢的轴向位置。膝关节的功能结果与髌下入路髓内钉技术所取得的结果相当。最终 LS 评分与患者年龄相关。
胫骨骨折;髌上入路;髓内钉固定;膝关节疼痛