Razmjou Helen, Christakis Monique, Kennedy Deborah, Robarts Susan, Holtby Richard
Department of Rehabilitation.
Sunnybrook Research Institute.
Physiother Can. 2017;69(4):351-360. doi: 10.3138/ptc.2016-41PC.
Recent care innovations using advanced-practice physical therapists (APPs) as alternative health care providers are promising. However, information related to the clinical decision making of APPs is limited with respect to ordering shoulder-imaging investigations and the impact of these investigations on patient management. The purpose of this study was twofold: (1) to explore the clinical decision making of the APP providing care in a shoulder clinic by examining the relationship between clinical examination findings and reasons for ordering imaging investigations and (2) to examine the impact on patient management of ordered investigations such as plain radiographs, ultrasound (US), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and magnetic resonance arthrogram (MRA). This was a prospective study of consecutive patients with shoulder complaints. A total of 300 patients were seen over a period of 12 months. Plain radiographs were ordered for 241 patients (80%); 39 (13%) received MRI, 27 (9%) US, and 7 (2%) MRA. There was a relationship between clinical examination findings and ordering plain radiographs and US (s=0.047 to <0.0001). Plain radiographs ordered to examine the biomechanics of the glenohumeral joint affected management (χ =8.66, =0.003). Finding a new diagnosis was strongly correlated with change in management for all imaging investigations (s=0.001 to <0.0001). Skilled, extended-role physical therapists rely on history and clinical examination without overusing costly imaging. The most important indicator of change in management was finding a new diagnosis, regardless of the type of investigation ordered.
近期将高级执业物理治疗师(APPs)作为替代医疗服务提供者的护理创新很有前景。然而,关于APPs在开具肩部影像学检查医嘱方面的临床决策以及这些检查对患者管理的影响,相关信息有限。本研究的目的有两个:(1)通过检查临床检查结果与开具影像学检查医嘱的原因之间的关系,探讨在肩部诊所提供护理的APPs的临床决策;(2)检查诸如X线平片、超声(US)、磁共振成像(MRI)和磁共振关节造影(MRA)等所开具检查对患者管理的影响。这是一项对连续的肩部不适患者进行的前瞻性研究。在12个月的时间里共诊治了300名患者。为241名患者(80%)开具了X线平片;39名(13%)接受了MRI检查,27名(9%)接受了US检查,7名(2%)接受了MRA检查。临床检查结果与开具X线平片和US检查之间存在关联(s = 0.047至<0.0001)。为检查盂肱关节生物力学而开具的X线平片影响了治疗管理(χ = 8.66, = 0.003)。对于所有影像学检查,发现新诊断与治疗管理的改变密切相关(s = 0.001至<0.0001)。技术熟练、角色扩展的物理治疗师依靠病史和临床检查,而不过度使用昂贵的影像学检查。无论所开具检查的类型如何,治疗管理改变的最重要指标是发现新诊断。