Roth M, Argyle N
University of Cambridge Clinical School, Addenbrooke's Hospital, U.K.
J Psychiatr Res. 1988;22 Suppl 1:33-54. doi: 10.1016/0022-3956(88)90068-4.
This paper reviews anxiety, panic, and phobic disorders as they were described in landmark works, along with more recent epidemiologic studies of the disorders. The author discusses clinical syndromes of anxiety as outlined in the DSM-III: agoraphobia, social phobia, generalized anxiety disorder, panic disorder, simple phobic states, and obsessive-compulsive disorder, relating them to Phobic Anxiety-Depersonalization Syndrome and to earlier descriptions by Westphal and Benedict. The paper addresses the problem of delineating anxiety and phobic states from depressive disorders, with regard to diagnosis and treatment outcome. Various etiological bases of agoraphobia, panic, and anxiety disorders are suggested: heredity, life events and circumstances, family background and developmental history, the premorbid personality, and some psychological aspects. Several questions are explored on the relationships of agoraphobia, anxiety and panic attacks. For example, is agoraphobia a new disease or one stage in the development of severe chronic anxiety? Are the phobias of agoraphobia acquired by conditioning or learning? Are "panics" spontaneous or physiological? Are panic attacks the first event in the primary cause of agoraphobia? For future work the authors propose a reassessment of the prevalence of agoraphobia and related disorders, a more careful definition of the agoraphobic disorders, and thorough clinical investigation of the various treatment modalities in well-defined populations. The past twenty years' achievements in behavioural and pharmacological treatments for agoraphobia are briefly recapitulated.
本文回顾了在具有里程碑意义的著作中所描述的焦虑症、恐慌症和恐惧症,以及这些疾病的最新流行病学研究。作者讨论了《精神疾病诊断与统计手册第三版》(DSM-III)中概述的焦虑临床综合征:广场恐惧症、社交恐惧症、广泛性焦虑症、恐慌症、单纯恐惧症状态和强迫症,并将它们与恐惧性焦虑-人格解体综合征以及韦斯特法尔和本尼迪克特的早期描述联系起来。本文探讨了在诊断和治疗结果方面,将焦虑症和恐惧状态与抑郁症区分开来的问题。文中提出了广场恐惧症、恐慌症和焦虑症的各种病因基础:遗传、生活事件和环境、家庭背景和发育史、病前人格以及一些心理方面。文中探讨了几个关于广场恐惧症、焦虑和恐慌发作之间关系的问题。例如,广场恐惧症是一种新疾病还是严重慢性焦虑发展过程中的一个阶段?广场恐惧症的恐惧是通过条件作用或学习获得的吗?“恐慌”是自发的还是生理性的?恐慌发作是广场恐惧症主要病因中的首个事件吗?对于未来的工作,作者提议重新评估广场恐惧症及相关疾病的患病率,更仔细地定义广场恐惧症疾病,并在明确界定的人群中对各种治疗方式进行全面的临床研究。文中简要回顾了过去二十年在广场恐惧症行为治疗和药物治疗方面取得的成就。