ENT Clinic, Policlinico SM alle Scotte, Siena, Italy.
ENT Clinic, Policlinico SM alle Scotte, Siena, Italy.
J Voice. 2020 May;34(3):487.e11-487.e20. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2018.11.001. Epub 2018 Dec 6.
Kinesio Taping (KT) application in speech therapy has been studied in a few works about dysphonia, facial nerve palsy, sialorrhea, atypical deglutition, postsurgical recovery after thyroidectomy and laryngectomy. The aim of this study was the evaluation of the possible role of KT in supporting speech therapy in singers complaining of dysphonia using singing voice handicap index (SVHI), fundamental frequency (F0), shimmer, jitter and harmonic to noise ratio (mean H/N).
We enrolled consecutive singers and singing students complaining of dysphonia and voice problems. Control group (DG1) was composed of 15 individuals who underwent traditional speech therapy only, while Case group (DG2), also composed of 15 subjects, underwent traditional speech therapy associated with KT application. A computerized voice analysis was conducted using PRAAT software observing F0, jitter, shimmer and mean H/N before (t1), at mid (t2) and after (t3) the treatment. Moreover, each patient filled in the SVHI before (t1) and after (t3) the complete speech therapy treatment.
The mean F0 and H/N measured before, during and after the logopedic treatment, showed a notable increase over time (P value <0.001) both for DG1 and DG2. However, no significant difference was found comparing the two groups. Jitter and Shimmer after treatment were clearly seen to be lower than before in both groups (P value <0.001), and followed a significantly different trend over time (P value <0.001). Moreover, unlike F0 and mean H/N, these parameters underwent a significantly greater decrease in DG2 compared to DG1. Lastly, SVHI improved at t and although these reductions were clear in both groups, it was greater in DG2 than in DG1.
Our findings are encouraging and suggest the possibility of using KT in case of vocal pathologies in singers. It is imperative to underline that the tape does not replace speech therapy, but could possibly enhance the effects of the treatment.
肌内效贴布(KT)在语音治疗中的应用已在少数关于发音障碍、面神经瘫痪、流涎、非典型吞咽、甲状腺切除术和喉切除术术后恢复的研究中进行了研究。本研究的目的是评估 KT 在支持患有发音障碍的歌手进行语音治疗中的可能作用,使用嗓音障碍指数(SVHI)、基频(F0)、颤动、微扰和谐噪比(平均 H/N)进行评估。
我们纳入了连续抱怨发音障碍和声音问题的歌手和歌唱学生。对照组(DG1)由 15 名仅接受传统语音治疗的个体组成,而病例组(DG2)也由 15 名接受传统语音治疗联合 KT 应用的受试者组成。使用 PRAAT 软件进行计算机语音分析,观察 F0、微扰、颤动和平均 H/N 在治疗前(t1)、治疗中(t2)和治疗后(t3)的变化。此外,每位患者在完整的语音治疗治疗前(t1)和治疗后(t3)填写 SVHI。
DG1 和 DG2 在治疗前、治疗中和治疗后测量的平均 F0 和 H/N 均随时间显著增加(P 值<0.001)。然而,两组之间没有发现显著差异。治疗后微扰和颤动明显低于治疗前(P 值<0.001),且随时间呈明显不同的趋势(P 值<0.001)。此外,与 F0 和平均 H/N 不同,这些参数在 DG2 中比在 DG1 中下降幅度更大。最后,SVHI 在 t 时有所改善,尽管两组都有明显的减少,但 DG2 比 DG1 减少得更多。
我们的发现令人鼓舞,并表明在歌手的声乐病变中使用 KT 的可能性。必须强调的是,该贴布不能替代语音治疗,而可能增强治疗效果。