Snapp Hillary A, Hoffer Michael E, Spahr Anthony, Rajguru Suhrud
Department of Otolaryngology, University of Miami Ear Institute, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Miami, FL.
Advanced Bionics, LLC, Valencia, CA.
J Am Acad Audiol. 2019 Jul/Aug;30(7):579-589. doi: 10.3766/jaaa.17121. Epub 2018 Dec 13.
The aim of the study was to determine if contralateral routing of signal (CROS) technology results in improved hearing outcomes in unilateral cochlear implant (CI) patients and provides similar gains in speech perception in noise to traditional monaural listeners (MLs).
The study is a prospective, within-subject repeated-measures experiment.
Adult, English-speaking patients with bilateral severe-profound sensorineural hearing loss using an Advanced Bionics CI (n = 12) in one ear were enrolled for the study.
Hearing performance in the monaural listening condition (CI only) was compared with the CROS-aided (unilateral CI + CROS) condition. Participants were tested for speech-in-noise performance using the Bamford-Kowal-Bench Speech-in-Noise™ test materials in the speech front/noise front (0 degrees/0 degrees azimuth), speech front/noise back (0 degrees/180 degrees azimuth), speech deaf ear/noise monaural ear (90 degrees/270 degrees azimuth), and speech monaural ear/noise deaf ear (90 degrees/270 degrees azimuth) configurations. Localization error was assessed using three custom stimuli consisting of 1/3 octave narrowband noises centered at 500 and 4000 Hz and a broadband speech stimulus. Localization stimuli were presented at random in the front hemifield by 19 speakers spatially separated by 10 degrees. Outcomes were compared with a previously described group of traditional MLs in the CROS-aided condition (normal hearing ear + CROS).
All participants were tested acutely with no adaptation to the CROS device. Statistical analyses were performed using Wilcoxon signed rank tests for nonparametric data and paired sample. Statistical significance was set to p < 0.00625 after Bonferroni adjustment for eight tests.
Significant benefit was observed from unaided to the CI + CROS-aided condition for listening in noise across most listening conditions with the greatest benefit observed in the speech deaf ear/noise monaural ear (90 degrees/270 degrees azimuth) condition (p < 0.0005). When compared with traditional MLs, no significant difference in decibel gain from the unaided to CROS-aided conditions was observed between participant groups. There was no improvement in localization ability in the CROS-aided condition for either participant group and no significant difference in performance between traditional MLs and unilateral CI listeners.
These findings support that unilateral CI users are capable of achieving similar gains in speech perception to that of traditional MLs with wireless CROS. These results indicate that the use of wireless CROS stimulation in unilateral CI recipients provides increased benefit and an additional rehabilitative option for this population when bilateral implantation is not possible. The results suggest that noninvasive CROS solutions can successfully rehabilitate certain monaural listening deficits, provide improved hearing outcomes, and expand the reach of treatment in this population.
本研究的目的是确定信号对侧路由(CROS)技术是否能改善单侧人工耳蜗(CI)患者的听力结果,并在噪声环境下的言语感知方面为传统单耳聆听者(MLs)带来相似的提升。
本研究是一项前瞻性、受试者自身重复测量实验。
招募了12名成年、说英语且双耳患有重度至极重度感音神经性听力损失的患者,其中一只耳朵使用先进生物电子公司的人工耳蜗。
将单耳聆听状态(仅使用人工耳蜗)下的听力表现与CROS辅助(单侧人工耳蜗+CROS)状态下的听力表现进行比较。使用Bamford-Kowal-Bench言语噪声测试材料,在言语在前/噪声在前(0度/0度方位角)、言语在前/噪声在后(0度/180度方位角)、言语在聋耳/噪声在单耳(90度/270度方位角)以及言语在单耳/噪声在聋耳(90度/270度方位角)的配置下,对参与者进行言语噪声环境下的表现测试。使用由以500赫兹和4000赫兹为中心的1/3倍频程窄带噪声以及宽带言语刺激组成的三种定制刺激来评估定位误差。定位刺激由19个扬声器在前半视野随机呈现,扬声器之间在空间上相隔10度。将结果与之前描述的一组处于CROS辅助状态(正常听力耳+CROS)的传统MLs进行比较。
所有参与者在未适应CROS设备的情况下进行急性测试。使用Wilcoxon符号秩检验对非参数数据和配对样本进行统计分析。在对八项测试进行Bonferroni校正后,将统计学显著性设定为p<0.00625。
在大多数聆听条件下,从无辅助状态到人工耳蜗+CROS辅助状态,在噪声环境下聆听有显著益处,在言语在聋耳/噪声在单耳(90度/270度方位角)条件下观察到最大益处(p<0.0005)。与传统MLs相比,各参与者组在从无辅助状态到CROS辅助状态的分贝增益方面未观察到显著差异。在CROS辅助状态下,两个参与者组的定位能力均未改善,传统MLs与单侧人工耳蜗聆听者之间的表现也无显著差异。
这些发现支持单侧人工耳蜗使用者在使用无线CROS时能够在言语感知方面获得与传统MLs相似的提升。这些结果表明,在单侧人工耳蜗接受者中使用无线CROS刺激可带来更多益处,并为该群体在无法进行双侧植入时提供了额外的康复选择。结果表明,非侵入性CROS解决方案能够成功改善某些单耳聆听缺陷,提供更好的听力结果,并扩大该群体的治疗范围。