Wang Lei, Zhang Xiaoshuang, Li Lu, Meng Liang
School of Management, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China.
Neuromanagement Lab, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2018 Nov 28;12:476. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2018.00476. eCollection 2018.
Social comparison implemented in an informational while not controlling manner can be motivating. In order to directly examine the effect of contingent social comparison on one's task engagement, we manipulated social comparison in an experimental study and adopted an electrophysiological approach to measure one' task engagement. In this experiment, we engaged the participants in a modified stop-watch (SW) task which requires a button press to stop the watch within a given time interval and instructed the participants to either play alone or simultaneously play with a same-sex counterpart. In the latter case, they could freely solicit feedback on their counterparts' performance besides their own. Enlarged stimulus-preceding negativity (SPN) and error-related negativity (ERN) were observed in the two-player condition, indicating strengthened anticipatory attention toward the task-onset stimulus at the pre-task stage and enhanced performance surveillance during task execution. As a complement, self-report data suggested that the participants were more intrinsically motivated to engage in the SW task when contingent social comparison was present. Thus, converging electrophysiological and behavioral evidences suggested the pivotal role of contingent social comparison in promoting self-directed task engagement.
以信息性而非控制性方式进行的社会比较可能具有激励作用。为了直接检验偶然社会比较对个体任务投入的影响,我们在一项实验研究中操纵了社会比较,并采用电生理方法来测量个体的任务投入。在该实验中,我们让参与者参与一项改良的秒表(SW)任务,该任务要求在给定时间间隔内按下按钮停止秒表,并指示参与者要么独自完成任务,要么与同性同伴同时完成任务。在后一种情况下,他们除了能得到自己表现的反馈外,还能自由获取同伴表现的反馈。在两人条件下观察到刺激前负波(SPN)和错误相关负波(ERN)增大,这表明在任务前阶段对任务开始刺激的预期注意力增强,以及在任务执行过程中表现监测增强。作为补充,自我报告数据表明,当存在偶然社会比较时,参与者更有内在动力参与SW任务。因此,电生理和行为证据的趋同表明偶然社会比较在促进自我导向的任务投入中起着关键作用。