Searles Bruce, Darling Edward, Riley Jeffrey, Wiles Jason R
1 Department of Cardiovascular Perfusion, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, USA.
2 Departments of Biology & Science Teaching, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY, USA.
Perfusion. 2019 May;34(4):290-296. doi: 10.1177/0267659118816036. Epub 2018 Dec 22.
Training students to become entry-level perfusionists requires evaluation and assessment of their clinical skills. While our professional organizations have compiled resources which identify the profession's knowledge base and categorical skills applied to clinical practice, these resources are lacking the necessary detail to develop validated clinical assessment rubrics. Therefore, the purpose of this project is to identify, through expert opinion, the detailed fundamental skills necessary to perform adult cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB).
We define a fundamental skill based upon frequency of use and risk of harm. A skill that experts report is conducted in >50% of their CPB cases - and, if not properly conducted, can cause harm, is deemed a fundamental skill. To identify these skills, a 73-question survey was developed and posted on PerfList and PerfMail from May 2017 to July 2017.
The results from 261 respondents were analyzed. The demographics of the participants were representative of the workforce. Twenty skills were surveyed and all 20 met the criteria to be identified as a fundamental skill. Data regarding the actions, assessments and behaviors that may be associated with fundamental skills were also identified.
Based upon this survey data, we have identified that there is consensus within our profession regarding the fundamental skills of adult CPB and a core body of actions, assessments and behaviors that experts perform when conducting these skills. This information may be incorporated into the entry-level educational process to inform curricula and design valid assessment rubrics.
培养学生成为初级灌注师需要对他们的临床技能进行评估。虽然我们的专业组织已经汇编了一些资源,这些资源确定了该专业的知识库以及应用于临床实践的分类技能,但这些资源缺乏开发经过验证的临床评估量规所需的详细信息。因此,本项目的目的是通过专家意见确定进行成人体外循环(CPB)所需的详细基本技能。
我们根据使用频率和伤害风险来定义基本技能。专家报告在超过50%的CPB病例中进行的技能——并且,如果操作不当会造成伤害,则被视为基本技能。为了确定这些技能,我们制定了一份包含73个问题的调查问卷,并于2017年5月至2017年7月在PerfList和PerfMail上发布。
对261名受访者的结果进行了分析。参与者的人口统计学特征代表了该行业的劳动力情况。对20项技能进行了调查,所有20项技能均符合被确定为基本技能的标准。还确定了与基本技能可能相关的操作、评估和行为的数据。
基于这些调查数据,我们已经确定,在我们的专业领域内,对于成人CPB的基本技能以及专家在执行这些技能时所进行的核心操作、评估和行为存在共识。这些信息可纳入初级教育过程,为课程提供参考并设计有效的评估量规。