Xie Heping, Peng Ji, Qin Mengyuan, Huang Xuzhe, Tian Fei, Zhou Zongkui
Key Laboratory of Adolescent Cyberpsychology and Behavior (CCNU), Ministry of Education, Wuhan, China.
School of Psychology, Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China.
Front Psychol. 2018 Dec 18;9:2580. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02580. eCollection 2018.
Because of the continuous stream of touchscreen apps that are claimed to be educational and the increasing use of touchscreen devices in early childhood, considerable attention is being paid to the effect of touchscreens on young children's learning. However, the existing empirical findings in young child samples are not consistent. In this meta-analysis we tested the overall effect of touchscreen devices on young children's (0- to 5-year-olds) learning performance, as well as moderators of this effect, based on 36 empirical articles (79 effect sizes) involving 4,206 participants. The overall analysis showed a significant touchscreen learning effect ( = 0.46), indicating that young children indeed benefited from touchscreen learning. Interestingly, age, learning material domain, comparison group, and experimental environment significantly moderated the effect of touchscreen devices on young children's learning outcome. These findings shed light on the role of touchscreen-related physical experience in early childhood education.
由于不断涌现出声称具有教育意义的触屏应用程序,以及幼儿对触屏设备的使用日益增加,触屏对幼儿学习的影响受到了相当大的关注。然而,在幼儿样本中的现有实证研究结果并不一致。在这项元分析中,我们基于36篇实证文章(79个效应量),涉及4206名参与者,测试了触屏设备对幼儿(0至5岁)学习表现的总体影响,以及这种影响的调节因素。总体分析显示出显著的触屏学习效应(=0.46),表明幼儿确实从触屏学习中受益。有趣的是,年龄、学习材料领域、对照组和实验环境显著调节了触屏设备对幼儿学习成果的影响。这些发现揭示了与触屏相关的身体体验在幼儿教育中的作用。