Lawrie G M, Morris G C
Ann Surg. 1978 Jun;187(6):665-76. doi: 10.1097/00000658-197806000-00013.
In order to determine which factors most influence late survival after the coronary bypass procedure, a review was made of the initial experience of one surgeon who performed 792 operations between 1968 and 1972. The initial 250 patients were compared with the subsequent 542 patients. The two groups were of similar age and sex and had a similar distribution of coronary disease and impaired left ventricular function. Perioperative mortality fell from an initial 6.8% (17/250) to 4.8% (26/542). The number of grafts per patient was initially 1.5 but later was 1.8. Graft patency beyond five years in 105 patients was 88.6% (148/167), 96.2% of patients had at least one patent graft. Initially, crude five year survival was 78.0% (195/250) but was 87.8% (476/542) in the later group. Patients who had no residual unbypassed lesions after operation had a 91.4% (287/314) survival while those with two residual lesions had a 66.7% (14/21) survival. Those patients with a preoperative end-diastolic pressure of less than 15 mmHg and no localized abnormality of contraction had a five year crude survival of 92.1% (316/343) whereas the patients with poor ventricular function had a survival of 81.8% (108/132). Our conclusion is that the most important factors determining late survival are the quality of surgical result achieved as shown by: perioperative mortality and graft patency; the degree of revascularization established; and the preoperative status of left ventricular function. The number of vessels diseased preoperatively had a minimal influence on late survival. These findings emphasize the primary importance of good surgical results in obtaining superior late survival rates.
为了确定哪些因素对冠状动脉搭桥手术后的远期生存影响最大,我们回顾了一位外科医生在1968年至1972年间进行的792例手术的初始经验。将最初的250例患者与随后的542例患者进行比较。两组患者的年龄、性别相似,冠状动脉疾病分布及左心室功能受损情况也相似。围手术期死亡率从最初的6.8%(17/250)降至4.8%(26/542)。每位患者的移植血管数量最初为1.5根,后来为1.8根。105例患者术后五年以上的移植血管通畅率为88.6%(148/167),96.2%的患者至少有一根移植血管通畅。最初,五年粗生存率为78.0%(195/250),而后期组为87.8%(476/542)。术后无残余未搭桥病变的患者生存率为91.4%(287/314),而有两处残余病变的患者生存率为66.7%(14/21)。术前舒张末期压力低于15 mmHg且无局部收缩异常的患者五年粗生存率为92.1%(316/343),而心室功能较差的患者生存率为81.8%(108/132)。我们的结论是,决定远期生存的最重要因素是手术结果的质量,具体表现为:围手术期死亡率和移植血管通畅率;血管重建的程度;以及术前左心室功能状态。术前病变血管的数量对远期生存影响极小。这些发现强调了良好的手术结果对于获得较高远期生存率的首要重要性。