Lara-Almunia Monica, Hernandez-Vicente Javier
Department of Neurosurgery, Son Espases University Hospital, Palma, Spain.
Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital of Salamanca, Salamanca, Spain.
J Neurol Surg A Cent Eur Neurosurg. 2019 May;80(3):149-161. doi: 10.1055/s-0038-1676597. Epub 2019 Jan 17.
Stereotactic biopsy is a versatile, minimally invasive technique to obtain tissue safely from intracranial lesions for their histologic diagnosis and therapeutic management. Our objective was to determine the anatomical, radiologic, and technical factors that can affect the diagnostic yield of this technique. We suggest recommendations to improve its use in clinical practice.
This retrospective study evaluated 407 patients who underwent stereotactic biopsies in the past 34 years. The surgical methodology changed through time, distinguished by three distinct periods. Different stereotactic frames (Todd-Wells, CRW, Leksell), neuroimaging tests, and planning programs were used. Using SPSS software v.23, we analyzed a total of 50 variables for each case.
The series included 265 men (65.1%) and 142 women (34.9%) (average age 53.8 years). The diagnostic yield was 90.4%, morbidity was 5.65% ( = 17), and mortality was 0.98% ( = 4). Intraoperative biopsy improved accuracy ( = 0.024). Biopsies of deep lesions ( = 0.043), without contrast enhancement ( = 0.004), edema ( = 0.036), extensive necrosis ( = 0.028), or a large cystic component ( = 0.023) resulted in a worse diagnostic yield. Neurosurgeons inexperienced in stereotactic techniques obtained more nondiagnostic biopsies ( = 0.043). Experience was the clearest predictive factor of diagnostic yield (odds ratio: 4.049).
Increased experience in stereotactic techniques, use of the most suitable magnetic resonance imaging sequences during biopsy planning, and intraoperative evaluation of the sample before finalizing the collection are recommended features and ways to improve the diagnostic yield of this technique.
立体定向活检是一种通用的微创技术,可安全地从颅内病变获取组织以进行组织学诊断和治疗管理。我们的目的是确定可能影响该技术诊断率的解剖学、放射学和技术因素。我们提出了在临床实践中改进其应用的建议。
这项回顾性研究评估了过去34年中接受立体定向活检的407例患者。手术方法随时间而变化,分为三个不同时期。使用了不同的立体定向框架(托德 - 韦尔斯、CRW、莱克塞尔)、神经影像学检查和规划程序。使用SPSS软件v.23,我们对每个病例总共分析了50个变量。
该系列包括265名男性(65.1%)和142名女性(34.9%)(平均年龄53.8岁)。诊断率为90.4%,发病率为5.65%(n = 17),死亡率为0.98%(n = 4)。术中活检提高了准确性(P = 0.024)。深部病变(P = 0.043)、无对比增强(P = 0.004)、水肿(P = 0.036)、广泛坏死(P = 0.028)或大囊性成分(P = 0.023)的活检导致诊断率较低。在立体定向技术方面缺乏经验的神经外科医生获得的非诊断性活检更多(P = 0.043)。经验是诊断率最明显的预测因素(优势比:4.049)。
建议增加立体定向技术方面的经验、在活检规划期间使用最合适的磁共振成像序列以及在最终采集样本之前对样本进行术中评估,这些都是提高该技术诊断率的特征和方法。