Roehampton University, School of Education, Roehampton Lane, London SW155PJ, United Kingdom.
Porto University, Faculty of Psychology and Education Sciences, Rua Alfredo Allen, 4200-135 Porto, Portugal.
Res Dev Disabil. 2019 Mar;86:41-52. doi: 10.1016/j.ridd.2019.01.003. Epub 2019 Jan 15.
Recently, the Children and Families Act 2014 was introduced in England to regulate provision for children with disabilities. According to this policy, statements of special educational needs were replaced with education, health and care plans, which should include high-quality, holistic and participation-focused outcomes to regulate provision; this change aligns with international recommendations regarding provision for children with disabilities. This study aimed to evaluate the outcomes defined for children with education, health and care plans in England. 236 Education Health and Care plans were included in the analysis, providing 2813 outcomes to be examined, which came from 11 local authorities and 42 schools and belong to 69 girls and 167 boys from 4 to 21 years of age. The outcomes were independently rated by two experienced researchers using a Goal Functionality Scale. Inter-rater agreement was calculated for 10% of the outcomes. Most outcomes were considered not to be functional or high-quality; differences in quality were found between local authorities, types of school, type of outcome, and the children's main need. There are important quality concerns regarding the outcomes that have been designed for children with disabilities in England, which should be addressed through standardised training and guidelines on procedures.
最近,2014 年《儿童和家庭法》在英格兰出台,旨在规范残疾儿童的服务提供。根据该政策,特殊教育需求声明被教育、健康和关怀计划所取代,该计划应包含高质量、全面和以参与为重点的成果,以规范服务提供;这一变化符合国际上针对残疾儿童服务提供的建议。本研究旨在评估英格兰教育、健康和关怀计划中为儿童定义的成果。分析纳入了 236 份教育、健康和关怀计划,共涉及 2813 项成果,这些成果来自 11 个地方当局和 42 所学校,涉及 69 名 4 至 21 岁的女孩和 167 名男孩。两名经验丰富的研究人员使用目标功能量表对成果进行了独立评估。对 10%的成果进行了评分者间一致性计算。大多数成果被认为没有功能性或高质量;在地方当局、学校类型、成果类型以及儿童的主要需求方面存在质量差异。对于为英格兰残疾儿童设计的成果,存在着重要的质量问题,应该通过标准化的培训和程序指南来解决。