International Centre for Eye Health, London School of Hygiene and Topical Medicine, London, UK.
Community Eye Health Institute, University of Cape Town, Groote Schuur Hospital, Cape Town, South Africa.
Eye (Lond). 2019 Jun;33(6):917-924. doi: 10.1038/s41433-019-0344-z. Epub 2019 Feb 1.
Currently there are a total of 780 post-graduate ophthalmology trainees in the United Kingdom (UK). Post-graduate ophthalmology training in the UK is 7 years in duration, and follows a comprehensive competency-based curriculum. Changes to training have been proposed as part of the government's Shape of Training paper.
UK ophthalmic trainees and trainers, in partnership with the Royal College of Ophthalmologists, designed a national questionnaire to explore the confidence of trainees in different clinical and non-clinical aspects of ophthalmology. The questions and possible responses underwent a process of refinement through the Royal College of Ophthalmologists Training Committee and Trainee Group. An online survey platform was used for the questionnaire, which was sent to all ophthalmology trainees within the UK. Reminders were sent via the Royal College of Ophthalmologists and Regional Training Programme Directors. A 4-week period was allowed for responses. Quantitative data were analysed, and qualitative data analysis included collation and thematisation of free-text responses.
A total of 188 trainees (24.1% response rate) replied. Ninety-four percent of trainees were in full-time training posts. The most popular career choice was oculoplastics (31.4%), followed by vitreo-retina (25.1%), glaucoma (24.6%) and cornea (24.0%). One-quarter had opted out of the European working time directive (EWTD), and 54.8% agreed that their work contract reflected the number of hours actually worked. In total, 34.4% of trainees thought that ophthalmic specialist training should be shortened from the current 7-year programme. Overall, 79.9% of respondents felt confident in performing phacoemulsification cataract surgery independently. For more senior trainees in years 4-7, 100% felt confident in phacoemulsification. However, overall, only 47.9% were confident in independently performing an anterior vitrectomy (91.1% of final-year trainees). Overall, 77.6% thought that all surgical ophthalmologists should be trained to perform cataract surgery. For non-clinical skills, trainees felt least confident in 'preparing a business case', with 64.5% disagreeing that they felt confident in this task. The most confidence was felt for communication with patients: 100% of trainees (all of whom have completed at least 2 years of medical work following qualification) reported feeling confident.
Most doctors in post-graduate specialist training in ophthalmology in the UK aim to specialise in surgical sub-specialities. The subjective reports collected in this survey suggest targets for strengthening of the UK's highly rated training system. Further research is necessary to determine overall satisfaction with training, the effect of changing training within the recent Shape of Training review; and how recent newly imposed junior doctor contracts as well as Brexit affects training.
目前,英国共有 780 名眼科研究生。英国的眼科研究生培训为期 7 年,遵循全面的能力本位课程。政府的《培训模式》文件提出了培训改革建议。
英国眼科受训者和培训师与皇家眼科医学院合作,设计了一项全国性问卷,以了解受训者在眼科不同临床和非临床方面的信心。问题和可能的答案经过皇家眼科医学院培训委员会和受训者小组的改进。问卷调查使用在线调查平台,分发给英国所有眼科受训者。通过皇家眼科医学院和区域培训计划主任发送提醒。允许回复时间为 4 周。对定量数据进行分析,并对定性数据分析包括对自由文本回复的整理和主题化。
共有 188 名受训者(24.1%的回复率)做出了回应。94%的受训者在全职培训岗位上。最受欢迎的职业选择是眼整形(31.4%),其次是玻璃体视网膜(25.1%)、青光眼(24.6%)和角膜(24.0%)。四分之一的人选择退出欧洲工作时间指令(EWTD),54.8%的人同意他们的工作合同反映了实际工作时间。总的来说,34.4%的受训者认为眼科专科培训应该从目前的 7 年项目缩短。总体而言,79.9%的受访者对独立进行白内障超声乳化术有信心。对于第 4-7 年的高级受训者,100%的人对白内障超声乳化术有信心。然而,总体而言,只有 47.9%的人有信心独立进行前玻璃体切除术(最后一年的受训者中有 91.1%)。总的来说,77.6%的人认为所有手术眼科医生都应该接受白内障手术培训。对于非临床技能,受训者对“编写商业案例”最没有信心,64.5%的人不同意他们对此任务有信心。受训者对与患者沟通最有信心:100%的受训者(所有受训者在资格后都至少完成了 2 年的医疗工作)报告对此有信心。
英国眼科研究生培训中的大多数医生都希望专攻外科亚专业。本调查收集的主观报告为加强英国高度评价的培训系统提供了目标。需要进一步研究以确定对培训的总体满意度、最近《培训模式》审查中培训变化的影响;以及最近新的初级医生合同和英国脱欧如何影响培训。